Research Article |
Corresponding author: Uthumporn Deesri ( uthumporn_deesri@yahoo.com ) Academic editor: Torsten Scheyer
© 2023 Sita Manitkoon, Uthumporn Deesri, Prapasiri Warapeang, Thanit Nonsrirach, Phornphen Chanthasit.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Manitkoon S, Deesri U, Warapeang P, Nonsrirach T, Chanthasit P (2023) Ornithischian dinosaurs in Southeast Asia: a review with palaeobiogeographic implications. Fossil Record 26(1): 1-25. https://doi.org/10.3897/fr.26.e93456
|
Ornithischian dinosaurs have been discovered in Thailand, Laos, and Malaysia. These bird-hipped herbivores remain relatively rare by comparison with saurischian dinosaurs. In the Late Jurassic, stegosaurs and basal neornithischians from Thailand showed similarities to Middle-Late Jurassic taxa from China. Ornithischians appeared in the fossil record again during the late Early Cretaceous (Aptian-Albian) of Thailand and Laos. They are represented by non-hadrosaurid iguanodontians and basal ceratopsians. A few specimens have been reported from poorly dated Early Cretaceous rocks of Malaysia. Here, we illustrate the diversity of ornithischian assemblages in Southeast Asia and discuss their palaeobiogeographical implications.
Cretaceous, Jurassic, Ornithischia, palaeobiogeography, Southeast Asia
Southeast Asia consists of a mosaic of microcontinents derived from the northern margin of eastern Gondwana which, after drifting northwards, collided with each other and with South China in the late Palaeozoic and Mesozoic (
Formation | Age | Taxa | Country | References |
---|---|---|---|---|
Xinlong | late Early Cretaceous (Aptian-Albian) | Napaisaurus guangxiensis | China |
|
Iguanodontian indet. |
|
|||
?Psittacosaurid |
|
|||
Grès Supérieurs | late Early Cretaceous (Aptian-Albian) | “Mandschurosaurus laosensis” | Laos |
|
Iguanodontian indet. |
|
|||
?Psittacosaurid |
|
|||
Khok Kruat | late Early Cretaceous (Aptian-Albian) | Siamodon nimngami | Thailand |
|
Ratchasimasaurus suranareae |
|
|||
Sirindhorna khoratensis |
|
|||
Iguanodontian indet. |
|
|||
Psittacosaurus sattayaraki |
|
|||
Psittacosaurus sp. |
|
|||
Gagau Group | ?Early Cretaceous (?Aptian) | Iguanodontian indet. | Malaysia |
|
?Tembeling Group | Early Cretaceous | Ornithischian indet. | Malaysia |
|
(?late Valanginian -early Hauterivian) | ||||
Phra Wihan | ?Berriasian-Valanginian | Neoanomoepus isp. (footprint) | Thailand |
|
Upper Phu Kradung | Early Cretaceous (?Berriasian) | Basal neornithischian indet. | Thailand |
|
|
||||
Lower Phu Kradung | Late Jurassic | Stegosaurid indet. | Thailand |
|
Basal neornithischian indet. |
|
|||
|
Southeast Asia map showing the distribution of Jurassic–Cretaceous non-marine sediments in Southeast Asia (modified from CCOP’s 1:2 million Geologic map of East and Southeast Asia), Number in circles = rock formations: 1, Lower Phu Kradung; 2, Upper Phu Kradung; 3, Phra Wihan; 4, ?Tembling Group; 5, Gagau Group; 6, Khok Kruat; 7, Grès Supérieurs; 8, Xinlong (
Josué-Heilmann Hoffet was the first to describe dinosaur fossils from Southeast Asia (
Most ornithischians in Southeast Asia are known from the Khorat Group of Thailand. After the first discovery of a dinosaur bone in 1976 from Khon Kaen Province, north-eastern Thailand, a Thai-French team began excavations in 1981, and more dinosaur remains were found (
The faunal assemblage from the Aptian Xinlong Formation of southern China shows many similarities to the Khok Kruat Formation of the Khorat Group of Thailand, especially the presence of the four endemic genera of hybodont sharks restricted to Southeast Asia and South China (
In Peninsular Malaysia, the Jurassic-Cretaceous rocks are mostly continental deposits, but the record of dinosaurs remains scanty (
The principal purpose of this study is to illustrate the diversity of ornithischian assemblages in Southeast Asia and southern China, focusing on Thailand where the majority of material has been reported, and to discuss their evolution and palaeobiogeography.
PRC Palaeontological Research and Education Centre, Mahasarakham University, Thailand.
SM Sirindhorn Museum, Kalasin Province, Thailand.
NRRU Northeastern Research Institute of Petrified Wood and Mineral Resources (In Honor of His Majesty the King) Nakhon Ratchasima Rajabhat University.
WNM Wittaya Nimngam Museum, Surin Province, Thailand.
Thailand comprises two major tectonic terranes: the Shan-Thai (or Sibumasu) block in the western part and the Indochina block in the eastern part that is separated by the Nan-Uttaradit suture (
The formation is considered as forming the base the Khorat Group which outcrops mostly on the Khorat Plateau in north-eastern Thailand (
SM2011-1-001 (renumbered from KPS2-1 in
Ban Khok Sanam locality, Kham Muang District, Kalasin Province; the lower Phu Kradung Formation, Late Jurassic.
Exceptional specimen of ornithischian dinosaurs from Thailand. Stegosaurid vertebra (A. SM2011-1-001), Phu Noi neornithischian left dentary (B. PRC149), Phu Noi neornithischian articulated skeleton (C. PRC150), Dan Luang neornithischian left femur (D. SM2016-1-081), Psitacosaurus indet. Right femur (E. SM2016-1-080), Psitacosaurus sattayaraki right dentary (F. SM2016-1-163), Khok Pha Suam iguanodontian dorsal vertebra (G. SM2021-1-113), Khok Pha Suam iguanodontian left femur (H. SM2021-1-118), Siamodon nimngami left maxilla (I. PRC-4), Ratchasimasaurus suranareae left dentary (J. NRRU-A2064), Sirindhorna khoratensis left maxilla (K. NRRU-A2048), Sirindhorna khoratensis right dentary (L. NRRU3001-167); A and G in anterior view; B–D, and H–J in lateral view; E, F and L in medial view. Scale bars: 10 cm (A, C–E, G–L); 5 cm (B, F).
This the first evidence of a thyreophoran dinosaur in Southeast Asia. The specimen is identified as belonging to the family Stegosauridae, which is more advanced than primitive taxa, such as huayangosaurid Huayangosaurus from the Middle Jurassic of China (
The anterior part of the centrum and the neural arch of SM2011-1-001 has been destroyed, but likely to possess centra of the dorsal vertebrae longer than wide as most stegosaurians, except for Miragaia longicollum (
PRC 149 (renumbered from PN 13-09 in
Phu Noi locality, Kham Muang District, Kalasin Province; the lower Phu Kradung Formation, Late Jurassic.
Buffetaut and his team reported a lower jaw (PRC 149) from the Phu Noi locality. The fan-shaped teeth with a strongly ridged crown and an asymmetric enamel distribution suggests that the specimen belongs to a small ornithopod dinosaur (
Many taxa of basal neornithischians, once considered as early members of ornithopods, have been reclassified as the basal neornithischians (
WNM-Ks-001, an isolated tooth (Fig.
Khok Sanam locality, Kham Muang District, Kalasin Province; the lower Phu Kradung Formation, Late Jurassic.
Basal neornithischian specimens from the lower Phu Kradung Formation. (left) Left dentary (PRC 149) from Phu Noi locality, in lateral (A) and medial (B) views; (right) isolated tooth (WNM-Ks-001) from Khok Sanam locality, in labial (if dentary) (C), lingual (D) and mesial/distal (E) views. Scale bars: 5 cm (A, B); 1 cm (C–E).
A dentary tooth shows the fan-shaped crown, and has the characters of the posterior teeth present in the dentary teeth of PRC 149 (
SM2016-1-081, a left femur (
Dan Luang locality, Kamcha-I District, Mukdahan Province; upper Phu Kradung Formation, ?Early Cretaceous.
Left femur of the ‘Dan Luang neornithischian’ (SM2016-1-081) in anterior (A), posterior (B), lateral (C) medial (D) proximal (E) and distal (F) views; Reconstruction showing the bone in left lateral view (G); Abbreviations: fh, femoral head; ft, fourth trochanter; gt, greater trochanter; mc, medial condyle; lc, lateral condyle; lt, lesser trochanter; pg, posterior intercondyle groove. Scale bar: 5 cm.
This is the first basal neornithischian specimen to have been discovered in Thailand, excavated in 1996, but it has not yet been described (
The left femur is robust and almost complete, except the distal end is eroded. It is 12.08 cm in length, and has a transverse mid-shaft diameter of 1.57 cm. The shaft of the femur is bowed in the lateral view resembling that of those early ornithopods and basal neornithischians, such as Hexinlusaurus multidens (
The Dan Luang locality has yielded mamenchisaurid teeth (
The Phra Wihan Formation underlies the Sao Khua Formation, is underlain by the Phu Kradung Formation and is dated as Early Cretaceous (Berriasian to early Barremian) by a rich palynological assemblage (
The formation is composed of reddish-brown, reddish-purple sandstone, siltstone and mudstone, with some conglomerate beds (
holotype NRRU-A2064, a left dentary (Fig.
Ban Pong Malaengwan, Khok Kruat Subdistrict, Nakhon Ratchasima Province; late Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian).
R. suranareae is a hadrosauroid (
The length of R. suranareae dentary is 19.81 cm, which is relatively small when compared to other skull material of iguanodontians from Thailand. It is not possible to determine if it is an immature or mature individual (
holotype PRC-4, a left maxilla (Fig.
Ban Saphan Hin, Khok Kruat Subdistrict, Nakhon Ratchasima Province; late Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian) (
S. nimngami shows a combination of iguanodontian features: maxilla shaped like an isosceles triangle, with the dorsal process located at about mid-length of the bone; a strong longitudinal bulge on the medial surface of the maxilla; maxillary teeth bear a strong median primary ridge, one short weak subsidiary ridge or no subsidiary ridge; and mamillated denticles on the crown margins similar to Gongpoquansaurus mazongshanensis and Probactrosaurus mongoliensis from China (
WNM-Sp-001 (Fig.
Some palaeontologists consider S. nimngami a nomen dubium as its material does not show any autapomorphic characters, and it might be referable to some of the other taxa from the same area (
There has been some disagreement about the type locality of S. nimngami given by Shibata and his team, and Buffetaut and Suteethorn; however, we would like to confirm that, after corroboration from the holotype collector, Mr. Witaya Nimngam, we now know that the type locality of S. nimngami is at Ban Saphan Hin. This is far from the type locality of S. khoratensis and definitely not from Ban Nong Rangka as previously suggested (Fig.
holotype NRRU3001-166, an articulated braincase including referred skull elements: a braincase articulating with a left postorbital (NRRU-A2035), dorsal half of a braincase (NRRU3001-65), caudal portion of a braincase (NRRU3001-179), a right premaxilla (NRRU-A3623), a left maxilla (NRRU-A2048) (Fig.
Ban Saphan Hin (a different site from the S. nimngami was found), Suranaree Subdistrict, Nakhon Ratchasima Province; late Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian).
It is known from the presence of several braincases and dentaries that at least four individuals are known. The holotype material, a braincase, shows an autapomorphy: a sagittal crest extending along the entire dorsal surface of the parietal and reaching the frontoparietal suture (
S. khoratensis is considered to be the best-preserved iguanodontian ornithopod in Southeast Asia (
Isolated teeth and postcranial material including: cervical vertebra (PRC 155); dorsal vertebra (SM2021-1-113) (Fig.
Khok Pha Suam, Na Kham Subdistrict, Si Muang Mai District, Ubon Ratchathani Province; late Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian-Albian).
Teeth of iguanodontians are common at Khok Pha Suam, but fragmentary (
The teeth of Thai iguanodontians exhibit a robust primary ridge displaced distally relative to the crown apicobasal axis, which is a derived feature of iguanodontians amongst ornithopods (
The maxillary teeth of Thai forms, including S. khoratensis (Fig.
Isolated Thai iguanodontian teeth; Sirindhorna khoratensis maxillary tooth (A, B. NRRU-A1959) and dentary tooth (G, H. NRRU3001-28); Siamodon nomngami maxillary tooth (C, D. PRC-5) and dentary tooth (I, J. WNM-Sp-001); Khok Pha Suam iguanodontian maxillary tooth (E, F. SM2021-1-122) and dentary tooth (K, L. SM2021-1-121). In labial (A, C, E), mesial (B, D, F), lingual (G, I, K), and distal (H, J, L) views. Abbreviations: ar; accessory ridges, pr; primary ridge, sr; secondary ridge. Scale bars: 0.5 cm (Modified from
The dentary teeth of the Thai forms, including S. khoratensis (Fig.
So far, three taxa of styracosternan iguanodontians, including S. ninngami, R. suranareae, and S. khoratensis, have been described from the Khok Kruat Formation in Nakhon Ratchasima Province plus one Laotian taxon “M. laosensis” from the Grès Supérieurs Formation of Laos. If Khok Pha Suam iguanodontian is one of the previously-named taxa from Nakhon Ratchasima, this would provide a geographic distribution of about 400 km to the far east (Fig.
If a high diversity in iguanodontians is present in Southeast Asia, then careful consideration and more materials will be required. This may be similar to the case of Edmontosaurus, the duck-billed edmontosaurine that was widely distributed in the Late Cretaceous (Campanian-Maastrichtian) ranging from Colorado to Alaska of North America, where several genera were consolidated into two species under a single genus, based on ontogenetic variation, morphometrics and several other factors (
holotype SM2016-1-163 (renumbered from TF 2449a by
Ban Dong Bang Noi, Lat Yai Subdistrict, Mueang District, Chaiyaphum Province; late Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian).
Apart from the ornithopods mentioned above, another valid taxon from the Khok Kruat Formation is a small basal ceratopsian. P. sattayaraki was described from a well-preserved dentary (SM2016-1-163) and a maxilla fragment (SM2016-1-164), and it is the southernmost known occurrence of this genus (
Although Psittacosaurus was abundant in the Early Cretaceous of Eastern Asia (especially China, Mongolia, and Siberia), it is worth noting that material of Psittacosaurus seems to be scarce in Southeast Asia. In Thailand, only fragmentary materials were discovered in Chaiyaphum and Khon Kaen Provinces, and have not been found in other Khok Kruat localities (
SM2016-1-080, a right femur (Fig.
SM2016-1-080 was collected from the banks of the Nam Phong River, Ban Bueng Klang Village, Nam Phong District, Khon Kaen Province; other materials were collected from Phu Hin Rong, Mancha Khiri District, Khon Kaen Province; all specimens belong to late Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian-Albian).
Additional postcranial specimens referred to as Psittacosaurus have been found in Khon Kaen Province (
Only the femur is still kept in the Sirindhorn Museum.
All of the dinosaur-bearing beds in the Savannakhet Basin belong to the top of the Grès Supérieurs Formation (
unnumbered specimen consists of vertebrae, ilium, and femora.
Muong Phalane, Savannakhet Province of Laos; Grès Supérieurs Formation (≈ the Khok Kruat Formation), Aptian–Albian.
Mandschurosaurus was the first dinosaur named from China, its material collected from the Late Cretaceous Yuliangze Formation (Maastrichtian) in Heilongjiang (Amur) River area between China and Russia (
unnumbered specimen consists of series of dorsal vertebrae, rib, pubis, and ischium.
Ban Lamthouay, Tang Vay District, Savannakhet Province; The Grès Supérieurs Formation (≈ the Khok Kruat Formation), Aptian-Albian.
These unpublished materials are kept in the Dinosaur Museum of Savannakhet. It is necessary to compare these with the unpublished postcranial material of S. khoratensis.
unnumbered specimen of left mandible.
Ban Lamthouay, Tang Vay District, Savannakhet Province; Grès Supérieurs Formation (≈ the Khok Kruat Formation), Aptian–Albian.
The unpublished specimen of psittacosaurid indet. was reported and the cast of this specimen is displayed in the Dinosaur Museum of Savannakhet (
This non-marine fossil-bearing unit was informally referred to as ‘the Pahang vertebrate bed’ and is located in the interior of Pahang State, but the exact location of the site has been kept confidential. Hybodont sharks and ray-finned fish fishes were reported from this assemblage, which have strong affinities with fauna in the Early Cretaceous of Thailand (
So far, the ornithischians from the Tembling Group have not been published, but some information was released in the Malaysian media (
Far northeast from the Pahang vertebrate bed, another dinosaur site was found in the Chichir River of Hulu Terengganu in the north-eastern part of the Mount Gagau Area (
Material of ornithischians was reported from the Napai Basin in south-western Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region (
The holotype, FS-20-007 to 008, a right ischium and ilium.
Napai Basin, Fusui County; Xinlong Formation, Early Cretaceous (Aptian).
This is the first named basal iguanodontian taxon from southern China, based on characteristics of the ilium and ischium which differ from other known iguanodontian taxa (
The authors did not perform a phylogenetic analysis of the taxon. It is necessary to compare with the unpublished ischium and ilium of S. khoratensis.
Unnumbered specimens including cervical vertebra, dorsal vertebra, distal end of left humerus, distal end of left femur, and isolated teeth.
Napai Basin, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region; Xinlong Formation, Early Cretaceous (Aptian).
These poorly preserved specimens cannot be identified more precisely. However, some lower teeth bear a strong median primary ridge and at least one subsidiary ridge suggesting a relatively advanced iguanodontian (
There are many taxa of iguanodontians in Thailand and Laos, but it cannot be concluded whether these materials belong to Napaisaurus guangxiensis or not.
Unnumbered specimens including distal end of a right femur.
Napai Basin, Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region; Xinlong Formation, Early Cretaceous (Aptian).
The origin of ornithischians remains controversial (
So far, Asian ornithischians have been found from five epochs as follows:
1) Early Jurassic
A few basal thyreophorans have been reported from Yunnan Province, China (
2) Middle Jurassic
A few basal neornithischians (such as Agilisaurus and Kulindadromeus) were reported from China and Russia (
3) Late Jurassic
As in Africa, Europe, and the USA, Asian ornithischian faunas were dominated by stegosaurs during this time. Some basal neornithischians are reported from the USA, China, and Thailand. Basal iguanodontians (such as Dryosaurus, Dysalotosaurus and Camptosaurus) evolved in North America, Africa, and Europe, but there is no evidence for these taxa in Asia (
4) Early Cretaceous
By this time, the number of stegosaurids decreased and these were eventually lost (
5) Late Cretaceous
The Beringian land bridge between present-day Siberia and Alaska, which opened during the Aptian-Albian, served as a migration route for terrestrial vertebrates between Asia and North America during the Late Cretaceous (
Southeast Asia consists of a mosaic of microcontinents. In the late Palaeozoic and Mesozoic, the northern margin of eastern Gondwana, after drifting northwards, collided with South China and other microcontinents (
Stage 1: Late Jurassic to Early Cretaceous
The oldest record of ornithischian dinosaurs in southeast Asia so far is from the Phu Kradung Formation of north-eastern Thailand, which is the basal unit of the Khorat Group (
Interestingly, the vertebrate faunas from the lower Phu Kradung Formation share similarities with the those from the Middle-Late Jurassic (Bathonian-Callovian) Khlong Min Formation of the Thai southern peninsula from the Sibumasu Terrane (
The upper part of Phu Kradung Formation is Early Cretaceous in age, based on the presence of Dicheiropollis etruscus (
The xinjiangchelyid turtles (such as Phunoichelys kalasinensis and Kalasinemys prasarttongosothi) from Phu Noi can be correlated with those from the Late Jurassic of China as follows: the Late Jurassic Shangshaximiao (= upper Shaximiao) Formation of Sichuan Basin, the Middle-Late Jurassic Shishugou, Toutunhe and Qigu formations of the Junggar and Turpan Basins, and the Middle Jurassic Chuanjie Formation in Yunnan Basin. In contrast, records of this group in Early Cretaceous deposits are scarce in Asia (
The presence of teleosaurid crocodylomorphs (such as Indosinosuchus potamsiamensis) from Phu Noi suggest a Middle-Late Jurassic age contrary to crocodylomorphs from the upper part, which are characterised by pholidosaurids (such as Chalawan thailandicus) and atoposaurids (
The saurischian dinosaur faunas from both the lower and the upper Phu Kradung Formation consist of mamenchisaurids and metriacanthosaurids, which are well-known from the Middle-Late Jurassic/Early Cretaceous Formations in the Sichuan-Yunnan-Northern Junggar Basin of China. Mamenchisaurids (such as Mamenchisaurus and Omeisaurus) are eusauropods, and are also present in the Chuanjie Formation, Shishugou Formation, lower and upper Shaximiao Formation, Suining Formation, and Penglaizhen Formation (
The single stegosaur bone from the lower Phu Kradung Formation cannot provide definitive proof, except that it is more advanced than the Middle Jurassic Huayangosaurus and likely to be closer to those from the Late Jurassic taxa, such as Tuojiangosaurus (
As mentioned above, the dinosaur faunas including metriacanthosaurids and mamenchisaurids, and basal neornithischians have been found in both the lower and upper parts of the Phu Kradung Formation indicating that, despite the change in other groups of vertebrate faunas, dinosaurs remained the same and had long stratigraphic ranges. Another noteworthy point is the Phu Kradung Formation, and the Klong Min Formation show a remarkable biodiversity and reveal a close relationship with Chinese Jurassic vertebrate assemblages suggesting that the vertebrate faunas are more widespread than previously thought. This is probably not surprising as the vertebrate-bearing terranes of Southeast Asia and China were fused by the Late Triassic and Mesozoic terrestrial sandstones are widespread from China south to Malaysia (
Stage 2: Early Cretaceous (?Berriasian to pre-Barremian)
The trackway of a small quadrupedal ornithopod is found in the Phra Wihan Formation of Thailand. This Formation was dated as Lower Cretaceous (Berriasian-Early Barremian) from a rich palynological assemblage (
The Sao Khua Formation of Thailand was assigned to the Early Cretaceous on palynological evidence (
The Sao Khua Formation is dominated by sauropods (somphospondylian titanosauriforms, other titanosauriforms and diplodocoids) and theropods (spinosaurids, megaraptorans and coelurosaurs) in terms of species-richness and overall abundance (
Phylogenetic relationships of non-avian dinosaurs in southeast Asia and southern China. Abbreviations: A, Sauropoda; B, Eusauropoda; C, Neosauropoda; D, Macronaria; E, Titanosauriformes; F, Somphospondyli; G, Tetanurae; H, Allosauroidea; I, Carcharodontosauria; J, Coelurosauria; K, Megaraptora; L, Ornithomimosauria; M, Genasauria; N, Thyreophora; O, Neornithischia; P, Basal neornithischian; Q, Cerapoda; R, Ornithopoda; S, Iguanodontia; T, Ceratopsia (
Although the late Valanginian-early Hauterivian seems to be a crucial period for the ornithischian dinosaurs in southeast Asia, it does not mean that they were completely absent, but possibly reflected niche overlap, competition between herbivores considerably, and/or different timing of biogeographic dispersal. However, the vertebrate assemblage from ‘the Pahang vertebrate bed’ of Malaysia shows strong affinities with faunas in the Sao Khua of Thailand (
The Early Cretaceous Phu Phan Formation is unconformably underlain by the red siltstones of the Sao Khua Formation, whereas the contact with the overlying Khok Kruat Formation is conformable suggesting that the Phu Phan Formation must fall within the interval early Hauterivian to Aptian, based on the ages of the over- and underlying formations (
Stage 3: Middle Cretaceous (Aptian to Albian)
In contrast with the Sao Khua Formation, the younger Khok Kruat Formation contains abundant neornithischian dinosaurs remains including iguanodontians and basal ceratopsians, fewer theropods (spinosaurids and carcharodontosaurians) and titanosauriforms sauropods have been found (
The Khok Kruat Formation of Thailand, together with the Grès Supérieurs Formation of Laos and the Xinlong Formation of southern China share the same palaeobiogeography, supported by vertebrate fossils (
Basal iguanodontians first appeared in North America, Africa, and Europe during the late Jurassic (possibly Kimmeridgian) (
The earliest known ceratopsians (or even marginocephalian dinosaurs) are in the family Chaoyangsauridae (Chaoyangosaurus and Yinlong), from the Late Jurassic of China (
After the Aptian-Albian stages, no further Mesozoic vertebrate fossils have been reported from Southeast Asia. The Khok Kruat Formation is unconformably overlain by the Maha Sarakham Formation (Albian-Cenomanian), which was deposited in a hypersaline, land-locked salt lake within an arid, continental desert, coinciding with worldwide high sea level in the Late Cretaceous and the flooding of marine-sourced water over what is now the Khorat Plateau (
So far, most southeast Asian ornithischian dinosaur fossils have been found in the Khorat Group of north-eastern Thailand. At least six taxa have been reported and dated from the Late Jurassic to the late Early Cretaceous. The oldest are known from the Late Jurassic Phu Kradung Formation represented by stegosaurids and basal neornithischians. There appears to be an absence of ornithischian dinosaurs during the pre-Barremian of the Sao Khua Formation. The Early Cretaceous Khok Kruat Formation (Aptian-Albian) contains abundant advanced iguanodontians plus basal ceratopsians, which reflects the shift from sauropod-dominated to ornithischian-dominated ecosystems. Iguanodontians and psittacosaurids are also found in the Grès Supérieurs Formation of Laos and the Xinlong Formation of southern China with many similarities to the Khok Kruat fauna of Thailand and these formations are considered equivalent in age. The rare dinosaur specimens from Malaysia are also an age anomaly. However, we propose that the ornithischian tooth from the Tembeling Group represents the existence of ornithischians that are missing from the time-equivalent Sao Khua Formation of Thailand. This study illustrates the diversity of ornithischian assemblages in Southeast Asia, providing an updated review and a discussion about their palaeobiogeographic implications.
We would like to thank many colleagues for useful suggestions and comments; Clive Burrett and Thitiwoot Sethapanichsakul for their help with the English language. Kamonlak Wongko, Sasa-On Khansubha, Wilailuck Naksri, and Kantanat Trakunweerayut for providing data on ornithischian specimen and map preparation. Witaya Nimgnam for material from Ban Khok Sanam and Ban Saphan Hin localities. We are grateful to the staff of the Palaeontological Research and Education Centre of Mahasarakham University, Sirindhorn Museum, and Northeastern Research Institute of Petrified Wood and Mineral Resources (In Honor of His Majesty the King) Nakhon Ratchasima Rajabhat University, who took part in our fieldwork and helped during visits to the collection. This research project was financially supported by Mahasarakham University.