Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Taniel Danelian ( taniel.danelian@univ-lille.fr ) Academic editor: Florian Witzmann
© 2026 Lusine Harutyunyan, Rémi Habert, Laurenz Schröer, Veerle Cnudde, Taniel Danelian.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Harutyunyan L, Habert R, Schröer L, Cnudde V, Danelian T (2026) Skeletal growth pattern of Protoentactinia gracilispinosa Kozur, Mostler & Repetski, 1996, a late Cambrian - Early Ordovician radiolarian species, revealed by X-ray tomography. Fossil Record 29(2): 759-764. https://doi.org/10.3897/fr.29.200748
|
Micro-computed tomography is increasingly important for the taxonomic analysis of early Palaeozoic radiolarians. It provides an opportunity to conduct detailed observations of the most internal parts of radiolarian skeletons in a non-destructive way. Our observations on 3D models of the species Protoentactinia gracilispinosa from basal Tremadocian strata of western Newfoundland (Canada) indicate that, during the first two stages of growth, the skeleton develops symmetrically with respect to the bar-centred entactinarian spicule. However, subsequently, progressive reduction of the number of rays placed proximally, combined with full growth of rays distally, results in the formation of an external subglobular shape during branching stages 6 to 8. Although our results confirm the previously assumed growth pattern of the skeleton, they reveal for the first time the number and pattern of branching iterations. More importantly, we establish that some stages of skeletal growth occur in a preferred direction, highlighting a clear heteropolarity of skeleton development, even though the end product is a subspherical spicular test.
Entactinaria, heteropolarity, micro-computed tomography, polycystine radiolarians, skeletogenesis
Polycystine radiolarians constitute a diverse group of marine planktic Rhizaria that secrete a skeleton made of amorphous silica. Molecular studies suggest the presence of skeletonless radiolarians since the Late Neoproterozoic (
The Cambrian and Ordovician periods are of key significance for the early evolutionary history of marine organisms, including heterotrophic plankton clades, such as polycystine radiolarians. Indeed, the siliceous skeletons of early Palaeozoic radiolarians testify to their significant diversifications and evolutionary changes (
During the last 35 years, significant progress has been achieved in understanding the taxonomy and biostratigraphy of early Palaeozoic radiolarians (
Based on Tremadocian (Lower Ordovician) material from Nevada, the species Protoentactinia gracilispinosa was first introduced by
The single specimen studied here (Fig.
Skeleton analysis of the radiolarian specimen was conducted at Ghent University’s Centre of X-ray Tomography (UGCT) in Belgium. The specimen was inadvertently lost during transport after all imaging had been completed. Although the physical specimen is no longer available, the description presented here is based on comprehensive microscopic documentation, acquired prior to its loss. The obtained scans were performed using the custom-built Nanowood micro-CT scanner at 70 kV, 4W and a voxel size of 900 nm. A total of 2322 projections were acquired at an exposure time of 1000 ms/projection, resulting in a total scan time of around 40 min. The projections were reconstructed using Octopus Reconstruction (XRE), following the in-house protocol, during which ring filtering and beam hardening corrections were applied. In this study, stacks of 2D images were processed using the 3D Slicer software. This open-source software is commonly used to extract structural models from images primarily used for clinical and biomedical applications. Image segmentation delineates regions within an image, in this case, structures of the siliceous skeleton. It is essential for visualising certain structures or for quantifying them (measuring volume, surface area and shape properties). The segmentation was performed semi-automatically. By manually scanning all the slices (hundreds of 2D images) in three dimensions (X, Y, Z) and using the segmentation tools provided by the 3D Slicer software, we were able to delineate the areas of interest in the radiolarian specimen by selecting the corresponding grey levels. Each part or segment could then be coloured, facilitating the overall interpretation of each branch within the 3D volume.
Colouring dissection allowed us to recognise eight successive stages of spicular branchings that result in the formation of a subspherical spicular test displaying a practically empty inner space (Fig.
Partial colour segmentation of the successive stages of skeletal growth of Protoentactinia gracilispinosa. Numbers situated on the upper right of each partially segmented specimen indicate the total number of new branchings/rays formed during each stage. A. Bar-centred entactinarian spicule formed during stage 1; B. The same bar-centred spicule seen laterally and placed tangentially against a hypothetical “central capsula” (blue sphere); C. Green parts illustrate the 6 new branchings/18 new rays formed during stage 2; D. Dark pink parts illustrate the 17 new branchings/50 new rays formed during stage 3; E. Light blue parts illustrate the 35 new branchings/108 new rays formed during stage 4; F. Yellow parts illustrate the 36 new branchings/109 new rays formed during stage 5; G. Grey parts illustrate the 17 new branchings/57 new rays formed during stage 6; H. Pale rose parts illustrate the 5 new branchings/13 new rays formed during stage 7; I. Pale green parts illustrate the 3 new branchings/9 new rays formed during stage 8; J. 3-D reconstruction of the entire specimen, with all its segmented skeletal parts coloured differently.
Type and number of new branchings and total number of new rays produced at each skeletal growth stage of the species Protoentactinia gracilispinosa.
| Growth stage | Single ray | Bifurcating | Trifurcating | Quadri-furcating | Penta-furcating | Hexafurcating | Heptafurcating | Total n° of new branchings | Total n° of new rays |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stage 1 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 6 |
| Stage 2 | 0 | 0 | 6 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 6 | 18 |
| Stage 3 | 0 | 2 | 14 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 17 | 50 |
| Stage 4 | 1 | 5 | 23 | 4 | 0 | 2 | 0 | 35 | 108 |
| Stage 5 | 2 | 7 | 18 | 6 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 36 | 109 |
| Stage 6 | 1 | 1 | 10 | 3 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 17 | 57 |
| Stage 7 | 0 | 2 | 3 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 5 | 13 |
| Stage 8 | 0 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 3 | 9 |
The first stage of successive branchings is represented by the formation of the initial bar-centred entactinarian spicule displaying two terminal trifurcating branchings developed at the two extremities of the median bar (Fig.
In terms of spatial development, nearly half of the final subspherical spicular test is formed at the end of stage 3. Starting with stage 4, shell growth is clearly unidirectionally and asymmetrically orientated, away from the initial spicule, establishing a clear heteropolarity in the skeleton growth and structural organisation, forming at the same time a more complete subspherical test. The distally orientated development of the shell is more obvious during stage 5. Most of the branches developed during stage 6 are generated on the opposite side of the initial spicule and in such a way as to form a subspherical shell. The few new branchings/rays generated during stages 7 and 8 are also developed so as to increase the subspherical aspect of the test.
Based on Tremadocian (Lower Ordovician) material from Nevada, the genus Protoentactinia was first introduced by
It is noteworthy that, during the first two stages of skeletal growth, the type of branchings is always trifurcating and, as this type represents the vast majority of total branchings formed during the skeleton formation, it may very well be that the trifurcating type is the standard and that all the other types of branching are possible malformations or simply part of the infraspecific variability of the species. However, in order to assess this, additional material needs to be analysed in the future. Although three specimens of Protoentactinia gracilispinosa were illustrated recently in Jiani Sheng’s PhD thesis (
Heteropolar development of a polycystine radiolarian skeleton has been recognised until now only for the radiolarians of the order Nassellaria. Here, we document for the first time the heteropolar growth of the test in a primitive entactinarian species. Indeed, the skeleton growth of Protoentactinia gracilispinosa recalls the heteropolar and unidirectional skeleton development described in Nassellaria, but without the axial symmetry characteristic of nassellarians, as the end product of skeleton growth of Protoentactinia gracilispinosa is a subspherical form.
Few studies provide insights into the function of polycystine radiolarian skeletal morphology (i.e.
Our analysis confirms the initial description provided by
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement no. 101005611 (EXCITE) / 101131765 (EXCITE2) for Transnational Access conducted at the Centre of X-ray Tomography (UGCT), Ghent University, which is funded by the BOF Special Research Fund (BOF.COR.2022.008). Furthermore, the authors would like to acknowledge the financial support for the Nanowood CT system (BOF Starting Grant, BOFSTG2018000701), as well as the FWO (G00972ON and G019521N) and the Faculty of Bioscience Engineering (FBW-CWO-UGent grant). Views and opinions expressed are, however, those of the authors only and do not necessarily reflect those of the European Union or the European Commission. Neither the European Union nor the granting authority can be held responsible for them. L. Harutyunyan is grateful to the Erasmus + KA171 Programme for funding her mobility for studies to the University of Lille during the second semester of the year 2024/25. Constructive remarks by the two anonymous reviewers and by the Chief Editor, Florian Witzmann, allowed us to greatly improve the initial manuscript. Vahram Serobyan and Charlotte Hunt are gratefully acknowledged for help with the figures and for editing the English, respectively.
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including the disclosure of any use of AI.
No AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation Programme under grant agreement no. 101005611 (EXCITE) / 101131765 (EXCITE2) for Transnational Access conducted at the Centre of X-ray Tomography (UGCT), Ghent University, which is funded by the BOF Special Research Fund (BOF.COR.2022.008). Furthermore, the authors would like to acknowledge the financial support for the Nanowood CT system (BOF Starting Grant, BOFSTG2018000701), as well as the FWO (G00972ON and G019521N) and the Faculty of Bioscience Engineering (FBW-CWO-UGent grant).
T.D. designed the study. T.D. prepared the material and supervised the project. L.S., V.C. and T.D. collected X-ray data. L.H. and R.H. treated X-ray data. L.H. and T.D. wrote the manuscript, with input from L.S. and R.H. All authors discussed and agreed on interpretation of the data.
L. Schröer https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3635-5180
V. Cnudde https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3269-5914
T. Danelian https://orcid.org/0000-0001-9496-2363
All data generated or analyzed is provided within this manuscript or in supplementary information files. The CT datasets studied in this work can be found online, on the YODA repository of Utrecht University https://doi.org/10.24416/UU01-6C8P0K.
Supplementary figure S1
Data type: tif
Explanation note: Different types of branchings and number of rays per branching recognised in this study. 1) Single ray; 2) bifurcating; 3) trifurcating; 4) quadrifurcating; 5) pentafurcating; 6) hexafurcating; 7) heptafurcating.
Dataset file
Data type: mp4
Explanation note: Partially rotating 3D micro-CT reconstruction displaying the successive skeleton growth stages of Protoentactinia gracilispinosa.