Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Christian Foth ( christian.foth@gmx.net ) Academic editor: Florian Witzmann
© 2026 Christian Foth, Oliver W. M. Rauhut.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Foth C, Rauhut OWM (2026) Considerations on the taxonomy of Late Jurassic Avialae (Theropoda) from the Solnhofen Archipelago. Fossil Record 29(2): 731-758. https://doi.org/10.3897/fr.29.200245
|
The iconic Archaeopteryx still represents the oldest known volant avialan, but its taxonomic history is complex. Several avialan specimens from the Solnhofen Archipelago have been variously assigned to distinct genera, most recently, the Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens. A recent reinterpretation proposed that all these Urvogel specimens belong to Archaeopteryx, based on similarities in limb proportions, with observed morphological differences attributed to taphonomic or ontogenetic variation. Here, the taxonomy of the Solnhofen Urvögel is reassessed by comparing limb proportions, conducting specimen-based phylogenetic analyses, reconstructing a forelimb morphospace, and re-evaluating the diagnosis of Archaeopteryx and possible morphological differences from the Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens. The phylogenetic analyses recover a monophyletic Archaeopteryx that also includes the Maxberg, Ottmann and Steil (“chicken wing”), and Karlsruhe specimens, which have so far only been tentatively referred to this genus, as they do not preserve its diagnostic characters. The Mühlheim specimen is excluded from Archaeopteryx and placed more crownward, a result consistent with its distinct position in the forelimb morphospace. The Haarlem specimen is found in various positions at the base of Avialae, indicating that its assignment to Archaeopteryx remains unresolved even when key character differences are silenced. Integrating these results with detailed morphological comparisons, it is concluded that the Mühlheim specimen is distinct from Archaeopteryx, supporting the validity of Alcmonavis poeschli, whereas the Haarlem specimen lacks definitive diagnostic features and is best regarded as Avialae indet. Specimens of Archaeopteryx probably represent more than a single species, but the results from different analyses are currently contradictory and inconclusive.
Avialae, Archaeopteryx, Late Jurassic, Solnhofen, taxonomy, phylogeny
The iconic Urvogel Archaeopteryx still represents the geologically oldest evidence of a feathered theropod dinosaur with volant behavior outside the crown group of birds (Aves L.). Although the plumage of Archaeopteryx resembles that of modern birds in great detail (e.g.,
Following the discovery of the first fossil in 1861 (
Since the second half of the 1980s, the pace of discoveries of Urvogel specimens from the Solnhofen Archipelago has increased considerably. Wellnhofer reported the sixth, Solnhofen specimen in 1988 and the seventh, Munich specimen in 1993. The eighth specimen—now the Daiting specimen—was briefly reported by Mäuser in 1997 but was not described in more detail until 2009 (
Despite this wealth of new information, one of the most basic questions about the Jurassic Urvögel of the Solnhofen Archipelago remains debated: how many taxa do these specimens represent?
The taxonomic history of Archaeopteryx is complex, and many specimens have been referred to separate species or even genera in the past (e.g., Griphosaurus for the London specimen; Archaeornis for the Berlin specimen; Jurapteryx for the Eichstätt specimen; Wellnhoferia for the Solnhofen specimen). This history is best summarized in Wellnhofer (
The newly discovered Mühlheim specimen was identified as a new genus and species, named Alcmonavis poeschli, and was found to be positioned slightly more crownward in the phylogeny (
The fragmentary nature and strong taphonomic compaction justify doubts regarding the most recent classifications of the Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens as distinct genera by
However, the analytical approach of
The current study re-evaluates the generic taxonomy of the different Urvogel specimens from the Late Jurassic limestones of southern Germany, with a special focus on the fragmentary Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens. For this purpose, the current study combines a specimen-based phylogeny including all 15 Urvogel specimens, a morphology-based principal coordinate analysis, and a statistical bone-by-bone length comparison of the preserved elements after allometric size correction.
Because the specimen numbers and names used here for the Solnhofen Urvögel differ somewhat from those applied by
Overview of all known Urvogel specimens and their taxonomic referral. BMMS, Bürgermeister-Müller-Museum, Solnhofen, Germany; BMNH, British Museum of Natural History, London, UK; DNWK, Datenbank National Wertvollen Kulturgutes; EMK, Evolution Museum Knuthenborg, Denmark;
| No. | Specimen name | Specimen no. | Taxonomic identification |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | London specimen | BMNH 37001 | Archaeopteryx lithographica (neotype of type species) |
| 2 | Berlin specimen | MB.Av.101 | Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 3 | Maxberg specimen (lost) | NA | cf. Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 4 | Haarlem specimen |
|
Avialae indet. |
| 5 | Eichstätt specimen |
|
Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 6 | Solnhofen specimen | BMMS 500 | Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 7 | Munich specimen |
|
Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 8 | Daiting specimen | EMK002 | Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 9 | Ottmann and Steil specimen (‘Chicken wing’) | NA | cf. Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 10 | Thermopolis specimen | WDC-CSG-100 | Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 11 | Altmühl specimen | DNWK 2923 | Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 12 | Schamhaupten specimen | DNWK 02924 | Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 13 | Mühlheim specimen |
|
Alcmonavis poeschli |
| 14 | Karlsruhe specimen |
|
cf. Archaeopteryx sp. |
| 15 | Chicago specimen |
|
Archaeopteryx sp. |
All specimens of Archaeopteryx were examined firsthand, except for the Maxberg and Chicago specimens. However, casts of the Maxberg specimen are available at the Bayerische Staatssammlung für Paläontologie und Geologie in Munich, and a cast of the main slab is also deposited in the Museum für Naturkunde Berlin.
Because crown birds represent the only living lineage of dinosaurs (e.g.,
For each Urvogel specimen, bone measurements were collected from
To test whether the two fragmentary Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens are morphometrically comparable to the sample of Archaeopteryx, a bone-by-bone length comparison was performed for both specimens. The estimated measurements of the tibia and metatarsus in the Haarlem specimen (provided by
Size differences among the Urvogel specimens indicate allometric relationships between bones (
The protocol was repeated for the two incomplete Ottmann and Steil and Maxberg specimens, whose assignment to Archaeopteryx is probable but cannot be demonstrated based on clearly diagnostic characters (
Finally, an additional bone-by-bone comparison was performed to test whether the Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens are comparable to the samples of the volant dromaeosaurid Microraptor and the basal non-volant avialan Anchiornis. Because the number of hindlimb measurements for Microraptor is limited, the main statistical comparison was restricted to the Mühlheim specimen using forelimb measurements only. However, a bone-by-bone comparison between Microraptor and the Haarlem specimen was performed for all overlapping elements preserved, and the results are presented in the supplementary information. Additional comparisons among the Ottmann and Steil specimen, Microraptor, and Anchiornis are also provided in the supplementary information (see Suppl. material
To illustrate the statistical differences, the p values from the bone-by-bone length comparisons were summarized in a similarity matrix and visualized as a heatmap. In addition, the collected p values from each comparison were log-transformed and visualized as boxplots to illustrate the differences among the comparisons. The equality of the medians and distributions among the log-transformed p-value samples was tested using two non-parametric tests: the Kruskal–Wallis test for equal medians (
In paleontology, the distinction of taxa is primarily based on comparative anatomy. However, this process is not always trivial because fossils are often incomplete and taphonomically deformed. Furthermore, knowledge of different types of intraspecific variation in extinct taxa is very limited because many fossil species are known only from a single, often fragmentary individual. Even in extant taxa, studies of intraspecific variation within the skeleton are rare. Thus, determining whether a certain morphology found in one specimen is representative of the entire species or is influenced by individual, ontogenetic, or sexually dimorphic variation is difficult and requires multiple individuals. Here, specimen-based phylogenies provide a means of assigning very fragmentary specimens to better-known taxa. In addition, this approach provides an opportunity to learn more about intraspecific and intrageneric variation in taxa known from multiple specimens and can also help resolve taxonomic issues involving these taxa. In the past, this method has been applied, for instance, to resolve the taxonomy of basal sauropodomorphs (
The phylogenetic dataset is based on
The dataset was analyzed in TNT v. 1.6 (
To explore the morphological distances among the different Urvogel specimens from the Late Jurassic of Germany, a morphospace was calculated in R, version 4.4.2 (
Because only 10–18% of all characters could be scored for the five most fragmentary Urvogel specimens (i.e., the Ottmann and Steil, Haarlem, Karlsruhe, Maxberg, and Mühlheim specimens), the first PCoA was not performed using the complete matrix. Because all fragmentary specimens preserve the forelimb, a reduced matrix that included only forelimb characters was analyzed instead. Although the Haarlem specimen is still scored for only 31% of the characters, the Mühlheim specimen reaches 76%. To verify these results, five additional matrices were created that included the sample of all characters scored for the Ottmann and Steil, Maxberg, Karlsruhe, Haarlem, and Mühlheim specimens, respectively. Given that all fragmentary specimens are scored slightly differently because of their poor preservation, this subsampling helps explore the robustness of the first analysis, which included only forelimb characters.
Subsequently, a regression of humeral length (log-transformed) against the first principal coordinate (PCo 1) was performed for each PCoA. Given that no humerus is preserved in the Haarlem specimen, the log-transformed length of manual phalanx I-1 was used. The respective PCo 1 values and their non-allometric residuals were applied to the single-case test mentioned above to evaluate whether the Mühlheim and Haarlem specimens are part of the Archaeopteryx sample.
An additional PCoA was performed that included not only the German Urvogel specimens but also other non-ornithothoracine Avialae for a broader comparison, allowing visualization of whether the Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens are positioned within the Archaeopteryx sample. These taxa included Anchiornis, Baminornis, Caihong, Chongmingia, Confuciusornis, Cratonavis, Fujianvenator, Fukuipteryx, Jeholornis, Jinguofortis, Jixiangornis, Kompsornis, Sapeornis, Serikornis, and Xiaotingia.
The overall differences between the Mühlheim, Ottmann and Steil, and Maxberg specimens (dataset I) and Archaeopteryx—indicated by the log-transformed p values from the non-allometric bone-by-bone comparisons using the single-case test—cannot be statistically differentiated from one another (Table
Boxplot comparisons showing the distribution of log-transformed p values from the various bone-by-bone comparisons. A. Comparison of the Mühlheim, Ottmann and Steil (“chicken wing”), and Maxberg specimens with Archaeopteryx (purple boxes), Anchiornis (dark green boxes), and Microraptor (light green boxes); B. Comparison of the Maxberg and Haarlem specimens with Archaeopteryx (purple boxes), Anchiornis (dark green boxes), and Microraptor (light green boxes). Statistical outliers are shown as empty circles or stars. The red line marks the 0.05 threshold for p values.
For the Mühlheim specimen, the only significant difference from Archaeopteryx was found for the comparison between metacarpal I (x) and manual phalanx III-2 (y). No difference was found for the Ottmann and Steil specimen. The Maxberg specimen differs from Archaeopteryx in the comparisons between manual phalanges I-1 (x) and III-2 (y) and PII-2 (x) and III-3 (y).
The heatmaps comparing the Mühlheim, Ottmann and Steil, and Maxberg specimens with Archaeopteryx show very similar color patterns, suggesting an overall similar variation in the proportions of all three specimens. In contrast, the color patterns of the comparisons of the Mühlheim specimen with Anchiornis and Microraptor differ from those of the previous comparisons but are not identical between Anchiornis and Microraptor.
Overall, the proportions of the Haarlem specimen cannot be differentiated from those of Archaeopteryx, Anchiornis, or Microraptor. Likewise, the Maxberg–Archaeopteryx comparison (dataset II) shows no statistically significant differences from the Haarlem–Archaeopteryx comparison (Table
Statistical comparison of log-transformed p values based on the modified t tests for the bone-by-bone comparisons of the Mühlheim and Haarlem specimens with Archaeopteryx and other comparisons. Significant differences in medians (Kruskal–Wallis) and distributions (Anderson–Darling) are marked in colored cells.
| Kruskal–Wallace | Anderson–Darling | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mühlheim vs. Archaeopteryx | H | p | Z | p | |
| Ottmann and Steil vs. Archaeopteryx | 0.688 | 0.407 | 0.473 | 0.220 | |
| Maxberg vs. Archaeopteryx | 0.300 | 0.584 | −0.221 | 0.458 | |
| Mühlheim vs. Anchiornis | 45.900 | 0.000 | 29.581 | 0.001 | |
| Ottmann and Steil vs. Anchiornis | 33.890 | 0.000 | 23.833 | 0.001 | |
| Mühlheim vs. Microraptor | 15.380 | 0.000 | 10.932 | 0.001 | |
| Ottmann and Steil vs. Microraptor | 4.943 | 0.026 | 4.371 | 0.012 | |
| Haarlem vs. Archaeopteryx | H | p | Z | p | |
| Maxberg vs. Archaeopteryx | 3.945 | 0.047 | 2,3004 | 0.033 | |
| Haarlem vs. Anchiornis | 1.009 | 0.315 | −0.161 | 0.424 | |
| Haarlem vs. Microraptor | 9.002 | 0.003 | 6,7789 | 0.002 | |
The great majority of all bone-by-bone length comparisons (more than 75%) are not significant in all four analyses. Although the Maxberg specimen is slightly more different from Archaeopteryx than the Haarlem specimen, the latter is slightly more similar to Microraptor and Anchiornis than to Archaeopteryx. However, as stated above, none of these differences are significant.
The Haarlem specimen was found to differ from Archaeopteryx in the following comparisons: manual phalanx I-1 (x) vs. pedal phalanx III-3 (y); manual phalanx III-4 (x) vs. I-2 (y); pedal phalanx II-3 (x) vs. manual phalanx I-2 (y); pedal phalanx II-3 (x) vs. metatarsus I (y); pedal phalanx III-1 (x) vs. pedal phalanx II-2 (y); pedal phalanx III-2 (x) vs. pedal phalanx II-2 (y); pedal phalanx II-2 (x) vs. pedal phalanx IV-1 (y); pedal phalanx II-2 (x) vs. pedal phalanx IV-3 (y); and pedal phalanx III-1 (x) vs. pedal phalanx IV-1 (y).
The heatmaps visualizing the differences between the Haarlem and Maxberg specimens and Archaeopteryx, respectively, show very different patterns in the individual bone-by-bone length comparisons. In contrast, the distribution patterns from comparisons of the Haarlem specimen with Archaeopteryx and Anchiornis are more similar to each other. Although the Maxberg and Haarlem specimens resemble each other in the variation in the lengths of pedal phalanges II-2, II-3, and IV-1, the Maxberg specimen is more different from the Archaeopteryx sample in the proportional lengths of pedal phalanges II-1 and IV-2 (Fig.
Heatmaps of the bone-by-bone comparisons showing the p values. The cells below the diagonal show the comparisons of the Mühlheim and Haarlem specimens with Archaeopteryx, respectively. The cells above the diagonal show alternative comparisons (see Table
Equal-weight analysis
Under equal weights, the New Technology Search found more than 200,000 most parsimonious trees with a total length of 4167 steps (CI: 0.194; RI: 0.731). The strict consensus tree recovered a large polytomy at the base of Coelurosauria, which included Compsognathidae, Alvarezsauroidea, and Therizinosauria (with Fukuivenator excluded), as well as subclades of Tyrannosauroidea, Oviraptorosauria, Dromaeosauridae, and Troodontidae. Avialae is excluded from this polytomy but shows another polytomy at its base, including the Late Jurassic taxa Anchiornis, Pedopenna, Fujianvenator, and Xiaotingia, Serikornis+Caihong, and all Urvogel specimens except for the Mühlheim specimen. Within this polytomy, the Berlin, Chicago, Ottmann and Steil, Eichstätt, Karlsruhe, and Maxberg specimens form their own clade.
The Mühlheim specimen, Alcmonavis poeschli, which is excluded from this polytomy, represents the sister taxon to the clade containing Sapeornis and Euavialae. This position of the Mühlheim specimen is supported by an angle between the proximal part of the humerus and the humeral shaft that is larger than 35° (char. 387/1); the presence of a facet for the attachment of m. deltopectoralis on the deltopectoral crest of the humerus (char. 413/1); a proximal articular surface of the ulna that forms an oval concavity with slightly raised rims (char. 422/1); a radial diameter that is between 0.5 and 0.7 times the ulnar diameter (char. 425/1); and a dorsal surface of manual ungual I that arches higher than the level of the dorsal extremity of the proximal articular surface when oriented vertically (char. 477/1). The recently discovered Late Jurassic taxon Baminornis (
The pruning of the basal coelurosaurs Aniksosaurus, Aristosuchus, Bagaraatan, Coelurus, Mirischia, Tugulusaurus, Xinjiangovenator, Xumenglong, the alvarezsaurid Albinykus, the troodontid Xixiasaurus, and the dromaeosaurids Balaur, Dineobellator, Dromaeosaurus, Graciliraptor, Hesperonychus, Linheraptor, Mahakala, Pyroraptor, Saurornitholestes, Tsaagan, and Zhenyuanlong using reduced-consensus methods results in improved resolution of the topology, especially at the base of Coelurosauria. Paraves still forms a polytomy, including Jinfengopteryx, Jianianhualong, Liaoningvenator+Daliansaurus, and a clade containing the remaining Troodontidae and Dromaeosauridae (Fig.
Specimen-based phylogeny of Archaeopteryx. A. Main topology of the reduced consensus tree under equal weights; B. Main topology of the reduced consensus tree under implied weights; C. Topology of basal Avialae under equal weights after the Haarlem specimen was pruned; D. Topology of basal Avialae under equal weights after the Haarlem and Munich specimens were pruned; E. Topology of basal Avialae under implied weights after the Haarlem specimen was pruned. Based on the topology, different species of Archaeopteryx can be assigned (see Suppl. materials
After the Haarlem specimen is excluded from the tree sample, the polytomy at the base of Avialae resolves such that the remaining Archaeopteryx specimens form a monophylum that is the sister taxon to the Alcmonavis–Euavialae clade. The Archaeopteryx clade is defined by the following character states: a triangular, anteriorly tapering snout (char. 24/1); a rod-like jugal quadratojugal process (char. 76/1); an anteroventral margin of the infratemporal fenestra with a sharply angled incision separating the quadratojugal and postorbital processes of the jugal (char. 79/1); fewer than 10 cervical vertebrae (char. 241/0); 14 dorsal vertebrae (char. 266/1); a gently rounded ventral surface of the posterior sacral centra (char. 294/0); a notch at the base of the ischial peduncle of the pubis in the position of the pubic obturator foramen in basal theropods (char. 521/1); pubic aprons that do not contact each other along the entire shaft (char. 526/2); and a non-ginglymoid distal end of metatarsal III (char. 603/0) (Fig.
Because the resolution of the internal relationships within the genus Archaeopteryx is beyond the scope of the current paper and requires additional detailed comparisons of character distributions among the different specimens, only brief comments on the internal relationships recovered here are provided, and the characters supporting the different groupings are not discussed further. A detailed analysis of the internal topology within the genus Archaeopteryx is currently in preparation and will be presented elsewhere. The Altmühl and London specimens represent two independent lineages at the base of the Archaeopteryx clade. The remaining specimens form a polytomy that contains the Munich, Solnhofen, and Thermopolis specimens, a Daiting+Schamhaupten clade, and a second clade. The latter includes the Berlin specimen and two subclades, one including the Chicago+Eichstätt specimens and the other including the Ottmann and Steil+Karlsruhe+Maxberg specimens. If the Munich specimen is additionally pruned from the tree sample, the basal polytomy resolves into a large clade including the Thermopolis, Solnhofen, and Daiting+Schamhaupten specimens (Fig.
Implied weight analysis
With implied weights (k = 16), the New Technology Search found 110,250 most parsimonious trees with a score of 145.23472 and 4,178 steps (CI: 0.193; RI: 0.730). The strict consensus tree shows a large polytomy at the base of Coelurosauria, also including the groups Compsognathidae, Alvarezsauroidea, and Therizinosauria (with Fukuivenator included), as well as subclades of Tyrannosauroidea and Oviraptorosauria.
Avialae, Dromaeosauridae, and Troodontidae, which are commonly grouped as Eumaniraptora, are excluded from this large polytomy. In accordance with the results of
Pruning the basal coelurosaurs Aristosuchus and Xinjiangovenator resolves the polytomy at the base of Coelurosauria. The general topology of the non-paravian taxa is consistent with the results of the implied-weight analysis of
After the Haarlem specimen is pruned, the polytomy at the base of Avialae resolves into three independent lineages. The first lineage includes Anchiornis+Caihong+Serikornis and thus corresponds to Anchiornithinae. The second lineage, which is closer to the crown, represents a monophyletic Archaeopteryx clade. Except for the presence of nine cervical vertebrae, all autapomorphic characters of this clade (chars 24/1, 76/1, 79/1, 266/1, 294/0, 521/1, 526/2, and 603/0) that were identified in the equal-weight analysis were also found in the implied-weight analysis. In addition, this analysis found further characters supporting this clade, including the development of a small preotic pendent by the otosphenoidal crest (char. 158/1); procumbent maxillary teeth in the mesial portion of the tooth row (char. 225/1); fewer than 25 caudal vertebrae (char. 298/0); no tuber along the dorsal edge of the ilium (char. 499/0); a pubic apron that measures approximately half the length of the pubic shaft (char. 525/0); a large, hooked proximodorsal process of the ischium that is separated from the iliac peduncle of the ischium by a notch (char. 548/2); and an enlarged hallucal ungual on the first toe (char. 617/1). Fujianvenator is placed more crownward than Archaeopteryx, forming the sister taxon to the clade containing the Mühlheim specimen and the remaining Euavialae.
After pruning, the Archaeopteryx clade consists of two main subclades. The first includes the Altmühl, Ottmann and Steil, Karlsruhe, London, and Maxberg specimens, which form a polytomy. After the Karlsruhe specimen is excluded, the topology becomes balanced, resolving into two subclades including the Altmühl+Ottmann and Steil specimens and the London+Maxberg specimens.
The other main subclade has a pectinate topology, including, from base to tip, the Thermopolis, Schamhaupten+Solnhofen, Munich, Chicago, Daiting, Berlin, and Eichstätt specimens (Fig.
Based on the forelimb characters, basal Avialae, Archaeopteryx, and Euavialae form three distinct clusters in the PCoA that are well separated from one another. The fragmentary Ottmann and Steil, Haarlem, Karlsruhe, and Maxberg specimens are placed within the Archaeopteryx cluster. In contrast, the Mühlheim specimen is neither part of the Archaeopteryx cluster nor of the other two clusters but is located in isolation in the middle of the three main clusters (Fig.
Principal coordinate analyses (PCoAs) of the phylogenetic dataset showing the positions of the Mühlheim (yellow) and Haarlem specimens (green). A. PCoA morphospace based on the forelimb characters of basal Avialae; B. PCoA morphospace based on the forelimb characters of basal Avialae from the Solnhofen Archipelago; C. Regression of PCo 1 for Solnhofen Avialae against log-transformed humeral length; D. Regression of PCo 1 for Solnhofen Avialae against the log-transformed length of manual phalanx I-1; E. Boxplots showing the variation in the residuals of PCo 1 against log-transformed humeral length for different character subsamples; F. Boxplots showing the variation in the residuals of PCo 1 against the log-transformed length of manual phalanx I-1 for different character subsamples. Archaeopteryx specimens are shown in purple, with those used for the statistical comparisons highlighted in pink.
The first PCo of the analysis using only the Solnhofen avialans accounts for more than 19.4% of the total variation in the forelimb characters. It has a weak but nonsignificant positive correlation with the length of the humerus (slope: 1.652; R2: 0.032; p: 0.542) and manual phalanx I-1 (slope: 2.591; R2: 0.072; p: 0.355), which is mainly due to the outlier position of the Mühlheim specimen (Fig.
Results of the modified t test comparing the Mühlheim and Haarlem specimens with Archaeopteryx for different character samples based on the PCo 1 values and their residuals. Significant differences are marked in colored cells.
| Mühlheim | Haarlem | |||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PCo1 | Residuals | PCo1 | Residuals | |||||
| Characters | t | p | t | p | t | p | t | p |
| Forelimb | 3.773 | 0.003 | 3.066 | 0.010 | −1.475 | 0.166 | −2.258 | 0.048 |
| Mühlheim | −3.093 | 0.009 | 2.340 | 0.037 | 0.860 | 0.407 | 1.291 | 0.226 |
| Haarlem | 4.743 | 0.000 | 3.392 | 0.005 | −1.782 | 0.100 | −1.928 | 0.083 |
| Maxberg | 5.664 | 0.000 | 3.995 | 0.002 | −1.989 | 0.070 | −2.693 | 0.023 |
| Ottmann and Steil | 3.234 | 0.007 | 2.465 | 0.030 | −0.658 | 0.523 | −0.940 | 0.369 |
| Karlsruhe | −3.317 | 0.001 | −2.341 | 0.037 | −0.064 | 0.950 | 0.108 | 0.916 |
According to
In their specimen-based analyses,
The two specimen-based phylogenetic analyses in this study suggest further characters that could be autapomorphic for the genus Archaeopteryx. These include fewer than 25 caudal vertebrae (char. 298/0); a ventral notch at the base of the ischial peduncle of the pubis (char. 521/1); a divided pubic apron that does not contact its counterpart along a portion of the pubic shaft (char. 526/2); and a metatarsal III without a ginglymoid distal end (char. 603/0; see
Based on the current revision of the characters, the genus Archaeopteryx can be diagnosed by the following combination of characters: a jugal with a longitudinal groove on the medial side of the suborbital process (
Archaeopteryx can be further distinguished from Anchiornis and other more basal Avialae by the presence of a large, hooked proximodorsal process of the ischium (modified from
The Maxberg specimen can be assigned to Archaeopteryx based on the lack of a ginglymoid distal end in metatarsal III. None of the diagnostic characters can be established for the Ottmann and Steil specimen or the Karlsruhe specimen. Their assignment to Archaeopteryx is based on character states that they share with a subset of other specimens referred to the genus.
In the past, limited specimen-based phylogenies for Archaeopteryx were performed by
In contrast to
The results for the internal Archaeopteryx topology differ between the equal-weight and implied-weight analyses. However, both topologies show that the London and Altmühl specimens are separated from the Thermopolis and Berlin specimens, which was also found by
In general, the equal-weight analysis is less well resolved than the implied-weight analysis. The sister-group relationship between the Eichstätt and Chicago specimens is based on a radius that is shorter than the femur. However, this proportion might be ontogenetically variable in Archaeopteryx (
The implied-weight analysis recovers two distinct main clusters, one including the London specimen and the other the Berlin specimen. Thus, based on this topology, the genus Archaeopteryx could be split into A. lithographica von Meyer, 1861 and A. siemensii Dames, 1897, which were previously recognized by
In summary, the current results of the specimen-based analyses do not help resolve the internal taxonomy of Archaeopteryx conclusively. Based on the results, either one, two, three, or more species can be justified, depending on the analytical protocol (unweighted vs. weighted analysis) or how the topology or noted differences are interpreted. If all specimens are interpreted as representing the same species, the name of this species would be Archaeopteryx lithographica, following the decision of the International Commission on Zoological Nomenclature to accept the London specimen as the neotype of the species instead of the single feather (
However, there are good reasons to assume that more than one species is represented by the 13 specimens that can now be referred more confidently to Archaeopteryx. First, and most importantly, the different specimens show considerable variation. This variation is evident in the morphometric characters, for which several specimens show at least a few values that fall outside the 95% confidence interval calculated for the values of all specimens (see, e.g.,
As noted above, if the two clusters of the implied-weight analysis are considered to represent different species, these would correspond to Archaeopteryx lithographica (for the cluster including the London, Altmühl, Ottmann and Steil, and Maxberg specimens) and Archaeopteryx siemensii (for the cluster including the Berlin, Eichstätt, Daiting, Chicago, Munich, Solnhofen, Schamhaupten, and Thermopolis specimens). Based on the results of the equal-weight analysis, the species Archaeopteryx lithographica would be restricted to the London specimen, whereas Archaeopteryx siemensii could be represented by the Berlin, Eichstätt, Chicago, Ottmann and Steil, Maxberg, and Karlsruhe specimens. Because the Solnhofen, Thermopolis, Daiting, and Schamhaupten specimens form a separate cluster after the exclusion of the Munich specimen in this analysis, this cluster could correspond to a further species, for which the name Archaeopteryx grandis would be available, as this name was suggested for the Solnhofen specimen (
As alleged differences in skeletal proportions were used to distinguish species within the genus Archaeopteryx (
Although
The main difference between Archaeopteryx and Anchiornis found by
A multivariate analysis of limb elements using data from all major axes of the limbs (humerus, ulna, radius, metacarpals I–III, femur, tibia, and metatarsals II–IV) might provide better insights not only into taxonomic differences among paravians and basal Avialae but also potentially into macroevolutionary patterns across the origin of birds and their flight. In this case, stochastic imputation might be useful for estimating missing values within distinct taxonomic groups, but for the use of this method, the coherence of such taxonomic groups should be established a priori based on diagnostic morphological characters. However, such a multivariate study across a broad range of paravians and basal Avialae is beyond the scope of the current paper.
The highly incomplete Haarlem specimen has a complicated taxonomic history (see
In addition to strong bone compaction, which is especially visible in the hindlimb region, the fossil suffered heavily from corrosion. This corrosion is characterized by more or less irregular dissolution pits, often with ragged and irregular margins. This type of corrosion is very typical of the plattenkalks of Jachenhausen, from which this specimen originates, but is rare or absent in other plattenkalk localities in Bavaria (
Haarlem specimen. A. Counterslab showing corrosion (black arrow) in the forelimb (scale bar: 20 mm); B. Illustration of the pelvic region of the Haarlem specimen by
In comparison, the few preserved remains of manual bones from the first and third digits appear quite intact at first glance, showing only minor signs of crushing. The preserved manual phalanges show remarkably regular-looking longitudinal furrows, and molds of such furrows are also present in the elements that are preserved only as impressions in the rock. These furrows were already noted by
Lacking obvious signs of crushing, the longitudinal grooves that are visible on the bone and in the molds were identified by
Although not included in the diagnosis, the posteriorly curved pubic shaft was identified as a character that the Haarlem specimen shares with Anchiornithinae (
Interestingly, in the original description,
Another character related to the pubis and noted by
The remaining characters used to distinguish the Haarlem specimen from Archaeopteryx and also used by
The heatmap visualizing the differences in the bone-by-bone comparison between the Haarlem specimen and the Archaeopteryx sample, based on the measurements of Wellnhofer (
The majority of the diagnostic proportions identified by
As previously recognized, the ungual shape of the Haarlem specimen overlaps with the variation seen in both Archaeopteryx and Anchiornis (
The specimen-based phylogenetic analyses identified the Haarlem specimen as a wildcard taxon at the base of Avialae that must be pruned from the tree sample to recover a monophyletic Archaeopteryx clade. In many of the most parsimonious trees, the Haarlem specimen was found at the base of Archaeopteryx but also within the Archaeopteryx clade, pairing with different Archaeopteryx specimens. In the equal-weight analysis, the Haarlem specimen paired only with specimens outside the clade containing the Berlin+Eichstätt+Maxberg specimens. Nevertheless, the Haarlem specimen was also frequently found outside the Archaeopteryx clade and instead placed at different positions at the base of Avialae.
In summary, the Haarlem specimen cannot currently be placed with certainty. None of the diagnostic characters of Archaeopteryx are preserved in this specimen, and the phylogenetic analysis does not place it consistently within this taxon, in contrast to the Karlsruhe and Ottmann and Steil specimens, which also preserve none of the diagnostic characters but are consistently found within Archaeopteryx. Despite the poor preservation, there are a few notable differences from other Archaeopteryx specimens, especially in the shape of the pubic boot and the tibia-to-metatarsus ratio, but also potentially in the flexed pubic shaft (see above). It remains unclear, however, whether these differences are sufficient to exclude the specimen from Archaeopteryx or whether they might represent intrageneric variation and possibly indicate that this specimen represents a species different from the other specimens. Indeed, the shape of the pubic boot is somewhat variable among the known specimens of Archaeopteryx. For example, compare the elongate—and still partially cartilaginous—boot of the Eichstätt specimen (
The Mühlheim specimen, which is known only from its right forelimb, was diagnosed as a new genus and species, Alcmonavis poeschli, that differs from Archaeopteryx and other theropods based on the combination of the following characters (
The second metacarpal of the Mühlheim specimen is considerably more robust than metacarpal III. The ratio of the mid-shaft diameters of the two elements is approximately 0.7; because of damage, the proportional difference between the widths of metacarpals I and II cannot be established. Depending on the specimen, the ratio between metacarpals II and III varies between 0.8 and approximately 1.0 in Archaeopteryx. The only exceptions are the Solnhofen specimen, in which the ratio varies between 0.6 and 0.7 in the left and right wings, respectively, and the Eichstätt specimen, with a ratio of approximately 0.7. The length-to-width proportion of metacarpal II in both specimens is similar to that of the Mühlheim specimen. Therefore, in agreement with
Several of the characters proposed by
Mühlheim specimen. A. Comparison of the humeral outline of the Mühlheim specimen (gray) with those of various Archaeopteryx specimens, showing the different angulation of the posteromedial margin of the humerus; B. Proximal end of the right ulna in the Mühlheim specimen, showing a well-defined, single, oval, concave proximal cotyle (scale bar: 5 mm); C. The same region in the Ottmann and Steil specimen, showing a flat articular surface (scale bar: 5 mm).
The elongate oval facet for the insertion of m. pectoralis, which is located distally at the anteromedial margin of the deltopectoral crest in the Mühlheim specimen, cannot be found in Archaeopteryx. However, the anterior view of the humerus can be observed only in the Thermopolis and London specimens and in the 3D reconstruction of the Karlsruhe specimen. Because the outer margins of the deltopectoral crests in the London and Thermopolis specimens are slightly eroded,
Like Archaeopteryx, the Mühlheim specimen bears a biceps tubercle on the proximal radius (
Finally,
Although the shape analysis provided by
The phylogenetic analyses support the distinction between the Mühlheim specimen and Archaeopteryx, placing it consistently in a more crownward position, as originally proposed by
Based on the present evaluation, Alcmonavis poeschli can be distinguished from Archaeopteryx and more basal Avialae by the following characters: an angle of approximately 38° between the proximal part of the humerus and the humeral shaft; a facet for the attachment of m. deltopectoralis on the deltopectoral crest of the humerus; an ulna with a well-defined, single, oval, concave proximal cotyle and a small lateral tubercle; a slender radius with a diameter less than 0.5 times that of the ulna; a large, crest-like biceps tubercle on the proximal radius; manual unguals with strongly developed, palmarly and transversely expanded flexor tubercles that are positioned close to the articular surface; a dorsal margin of manual ungual I that arches higher than the proximal articular surface; and a dorsal margin of manual ungual II that is level with the proximal articular surface. The Mühlheim specimen can be distinguished from Avialae closer to the crown group by having an ulna that is shorter than the humerus. It differs from Jeholornithidae by possessing a straight, closely appressed metacarpal III and lacking an intermetacarpal space. It differs from Sapeornithidae by having a fully developed third manual digit consisting of four phalanges, including the ungual.
Apart from the Haarlem and Mühlheim specimens, the specimen-based phylogeny found that all Urvogel specimens from the Late Jurassic of southern Germany, including the Solnhofen specimen, form a monophyletic group that represents the genus Archaeopteryx. Based on these findings, the diagnosis of Archaeopteryx was updated. The internal topologies of the analyses did not yet allow the distinction of different Archaeopteryx species. Thus, further anatomical comparisons are necessary to identify additional intrageneric variation that can be conceptualized as morphological characters.
Because of inconsistencies in its phylogenetic position, it is unclear whether the Haarlem specimen represents another Archaeopteryx specimen or a more basal representative of Avialae. Although several morphological features previously described by
In contrast, the incomplete Mühlheim specimen is very similar to Archaeopteryx in its general forelimb proportions but differs from the paravians Anchiornis and Microraptor in its manual proportions. However, morphological comparisons, phylogenetic analyses, principal coordinate analyses, and subsequent statistical tests indicate that the specimen is anatomically distinct from Archaeopteryx, supporting the validity of the taxon Alcmonavis poeschli. Although some of the original diagnostic characters are now also interpreted as preservational artifacts, the remaining differences from Archaeopteryx are distinct and cannot be explained by ontogeny or other types of intrageneric variation. The strong similarities observed in forelimb proportions are most likely due to functional constraints in the forelimbs of early Avialae related to volant behavior (
Based on the different statistical outcomes for the measurements of the Haarlem specimen provided by Wellnhofer (
In addition, the phylogenetic analyses support the previous findings of
Finally, the forelimb morphospace of basal Avialae shows three distinct clusters for non-volant Avialae, Archaeopteryx, and Euavialae. However, the arrangement of the clusters does not indicate a linear evolutionary trend from non-volant to volant taxa in the forelimbs because of the outlier position of the Archaeopteryx cluster along PCo 2. This finding may indicate that flight adaptations occurring in the forelimbs followed mosaic-like evolution, which requires a more sophisticated macroevolutionary analysis.
The authors thank Anne Schulp and Hermann Voogd for access to the Haarlem specimen. The authors further thank two anonymous reviewers and the editor, Florian Witzmann, for their critical comments on the manuscript. The study was supported by the German Research Foundation (DFG) (Heisenberg Fellowship, Grant No. 562995972 to CF), the Swiss National Science Foundation (Grant No. PZ00P2_174040 to CF), and the Volkswagen Stiftung (Grant No. 8640 to OR).
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
No ethical statement was reported.
The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including the disclosure of any use of AI.
No AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.
The study was supported by the German Research Foundation (DFG) (Heisenberg Fellowship, Grant No. 562995972 to CF), the Swiss National Science Foundation (Grant No. PZ00P2_174040 to CF), and the Volkswagen Stiftung (Grant No. 8640 to OR).
CF and OWMR designed the project; CF performed all analyses; CF and OWMR wrote the manuscript; CF prepared all tables, figures and supplementary files.
C. Foth https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9410-4569
O.W.M. Rauhut https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3958-603X
All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.
Supplementary tables, figures and character list for phylogenetic analysis
Data type: pdf
Measurements used for statistical analyses
Data type: xlsx
Mesquite data file
Data type: txt
TNT data file
Data type: txt
Strict consensus tree of phylogenetic analysis with all characters equally weighted
Data type: pdf
Reduced consensus tree of phylogenetic analysis with all characters equally weighted
Data type: pdf
Strict consensus tree of phylogenetic analysis with implied weighted
Data type: pdf
Reduced consensus tree of phylogenetic analysis with implied weighted
Data type: pdf