Research Article |
Corresponding author: Dorota Konietzko-Meier ( dorota.konietzko-meier@smns-bw.de ) Academic editor: Florian Witzmann
© 2025 Dorota Konietzko-Meier, Andrea Prino, Elżbieta M. Teschner.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Konietzko-Meier D, Prino A, Teschner EM (2025) Hips do not lie… histology of the pelvic girdle elements of Metoposaurus from the Late Triassic of Poland. Fossil Record 28(1): 165-178. https://doi.org/10.3897/fr.28.e153929
|
The pelvic elements are among the least histologically studied skeletal elements of Temnospondyli, despite the fact that their histological framework can provide a lot of information about skeletochronology and function. One of the best histologically known taxon is Metoposaurus krasiejowensis from the Late Triassic of Krasiejów. To complete the histological studies of that taxon and obtain information about the intraskeletal variability, three ilia representing different ontogenetical stages and one ischium were sectioned. Microanatomically, all pelvic elements are porous, with a thin cortex, except for the midpart of the dorsal blade of the ilium. The dominating matrix type is coarse parallel-fibred bone, and growth marks are represented by thick zones and unusually thick annuli, always hosting few rest lines. Lines of Arrested Growth (LAGs) are not present. Sharpey’s fibers are dense, especially laterally in the ilia. Typical for the ischium is a preservation of calcified cartilage. The histological framework is comparable to that known from long bones of the same taxon from the same size class representing similar growth patterns. The extended presence of calcified cartilage has already been described for intercentra indicating the slow ossification of the endochondral domain. Low compactness of all pelvic elements may suggest the reduced function of the pelvic girdle and hind limbs in locomotion of Metoposaurus.
Growth marks, growth pattern, ilium, ischium, Krasiejów, palaeohistology
The morphological change of the pelvic girdle was one of the key modifications crucial for the evolution of tetrapods, which relied more heavily on their hindlimbs for locomotion. In sarcopterygians, the pelvic girdle is a crescent-shaped bone (pelvis) attached to the body wall musculature and not to the vertebral column (
The tetrapod-type pelvis already appeared in Tiktaalik rosae, where the transitional fish-tetrapod stage of the pelvis structure was recently described (
Among temnospondyls, the pelvis is composed of three bones: the paired ilia, ischia and when ossified, two pubes (Fig.
Schematic drawings of pelvic elements. A. The idealized reconstruction of the left pelvis of the Lower Permian Eryops sp. (based on
Among Eryopidae the pelvic girdle is massively built (
Despite the importance of the pelvic girdle in the evolution of tetrapods with large changes in its size and morphology, it is one of the least studied elements of the skeleton among early tetrapods. The main line of studies involving the pelvic characters focuses usually around the fin-limb transition stage, including sarcopterygian fishes and early Tetrapodomorpha (e.g.
Equally rare are histological studies of the pelvic elements and any existing studies are limited only to temnospondyls. The histological study of ilium of the basal stereospondyl Rhinesuchus shows that this element preserved the greatest amount of Lines of Arrested Growth (LAGs) among all sectioned skeletal elements with the dorsal process of the ilium being the best approximation of minimum individual age (
One of the best histologically studied taxa of Temnospondyli is Metoposaurus krasiejowensis from the Late Triassic of Poland (
Articulated skeletons of Metoposauridae, including pelvic elements, are known for Dutuitosaurus ouazzoui from the Late Triassic of Morocco (
In the light of the highly limited access to temnospondyl postcrania, it is worth testing pelvic bones for their relevance to skeletochronological analyses and for its environmental signal as a good substitution for long bones. Thus, the main goals of this study are to investigate the histology of the ilium and the ischium in order to evaluate the preservation of the growth marks in both pelvic elements relatively to other skeletal elements.
Three ilia (UOPB 00055, UOBS 02917 and UOBS 02916) and one ischium (UOPB 00037) from the Late Triassic of Krasiejów were sectioned (Table
Measurements and age estimation of Metoposaurus krasiejowensis pelvic bones from the Late Triassic of Poland.
Col. Num. | Skeletal element | a (mm) | b (mm) | c (mm) | d (mm) | Estimated length of the femur1 | Estimated age in years of the femur2 | Sequence of growth marks preserved in pelvic elements3 | Estimated age in years of the pelvic elements |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
UOBS 02916 | ilium (right) | 89,5 | 47,4 | 21,5 | 21 | 89,9 mm | 4-5 | -rem | 4-5 |
-1st a (rl) | |||||||||
UOPB 00055 | ilium (right) | 63 | 32 | 15,6 | 12,3 | 63 mm | 2-3 | -rem | 3 |
-1st z | |||||||||
-1st a (rl) | |||||||||
-2nd z | |||||||||
-2nd a (rl) | |||||||||
UOBS 02917 | ilium (right) | 55,2 | 22,8/23* | 17,2 | 11,0 | 55,2 mm | 1 | -rem | 1-2 |
-1st z | |||||||||
-1st a | |||||||||
UOPB 00037 | ischium (left) | 34 | 37,5 | – | – | 62,5 mm | 2 | -rem | 2-3 |
-1 st a | |||||||||
-1st z | |||||||||
-2nd a (rl) |
The individual age of pelvic elements was calculated based on the amount of visible growth marks and the retrocalculation of the missing cycles (de
The proportion between pelvic elements and between ilium and femur were estimated based on the numerous articulated skeletons of the closely related metoposaurid Dutuitosaurus ouazzoui from the Late Triassic of Morocco, (Dutuit, 1976; pers. obs. DKM). In Dutuitosaurus the length of the dorsolateral edge of the ischium is about 0.6 times of the total length of the ilium. The length of the ilium when compared to the femur is between 95% to 100% of the length of the femur. For this research the length of the ilium was taken as equal to the femur.
The ilia were sampled in the middle part of the dorsal iliac processes (Fig.
The thin-sections were prepared according to the procedure described by
Ilia – The overall morphology of the three specimens is very similar, with a narrow dorsal iliac blade and a wide triangular base (Fig.
Ischium – The ischium (UOBS 00837) has a semicircular shape with the round edge facing ventromedially and the straight thin edge dorsolaterally (Fig.
Ilia – The smallest ilium UOBS 02917 has a nearly rounded cross-sectional shape with a very gentle rugosity visible on the lateral side of the section (Fig.
The histology of the midshaft of the ilia of Metoposaurus krasiejowensis from the Late Triassic of Krasiejów. A-F. Ilium UOBS 02917; G-M. Ilium UOPB 00055; N-R. Ilium UOBS 02916. A. Cross section of the iliac dorsal blade; B. Close-up of the lateral side of the section in A, image in plane polarized light; C. The same image as B, in cross-polarized light; D. Close-up of the medial edge of the section in A, in plane polarized light; E. Same image as D, in cross polarized light; F. Details of the matrix showing two types of collagen fibers organization, close up from E, in cross polarized light; G. Virtual longitudinal section of the ilium UOPB 00055 in posterior view; H. Cross section of the iliac dorsal blade; I. Close-up of the lateral side of the section in H, image in plane polarized light; J. The same image as I, in cross-polarized light; K. Close-up of the medial edge of the section in H, in plane polarized light; E. Same image as K, in cross polarized light; M. Details of the matrix showing two types of organization and rest lines; N. Cross section of the iliac dorsal blade; O. Close-up of the lateral side of the section in N, image in plane polarized light; P. The same image as O, in cross-polarized light; Q. Close-up of the medial edge of the section in N, in plane polarized light; R. same image as P, in cross polarized light. Abbreviations: a – annulus, ant. – anterior, c-pfb – coarse parallel-fibred bone, e.c. – erosion cavity, f-pfb – fine parallel-fibred bone, lat. – lateral, p.o. – primary osteons, s.o. – secondary osteons, S.f. – Sharpey’s fibers, s.v. – simple vascular canals, z – zone, arrows indicate rest lines.
The micro-CT-scan of the ilium UOPB 00055 shows that the most compact part of the entire bone is the middle segment of the blade, whereas the base and the top of the blade are highly porous (Fig.
The largest ilium (UOBS 02916) is almost twice as large as the smallest one (UOBS 02917) (Table
Ischium - The cross section along the coronal plane has a shape of an elongated triangle with the top representing the dorsolateral edge and the wider bottom corresponding to the ventromedial edge (Fig.
The histology of the ischium UOBS 00837 of Metoposaurus krasiejowensis from the Late Triassic of Krasiejów. A-G. Histological framework in coronal section (see Fig.
The primary matrix, similar to the ilia, varies between coarse, typical for a zone, and fine parallel-fibred bone, present in the annuli, with the fibers aligned dorsolaterally-medioventrally (Fig.
The transverse section of the ischium represents only the anterior part of the section with the widest edge corresponding to the anterior surface (Fig.
In general, the shape of the ilium is diverse within temnospondyls, and not only between families, but also within them, showing a great degree of intraspecific variation (
Ontogenetically, the best studied variability of the ilia is known from that of Benthosuchus sushkini (
The three ilia tested here fit well into the ontogenetic pattern proposed by
The overall intraspecific morphological variability can be triggered by many factors, like among others, ontogeny, environmental constraints, ecological adaptations, plasticity due to functional needs, sexual dimorphism or pathologies. For localities with at least two temnospondyl species co-occurring, as it is in Krasiejów with Metoposaurus krasiejowensis and Cyclotosaurus intermedius (
Whereas the assignment of disarticulated bones to a specific genus or species can be problematic due to morphological similarities, paleohistology holds the potential to come to the rescue (
Cyclotosaurus histology is known only from two large humeri originating from two localities, Bonenburg (
Among bones tested here the growth pattern typical for Metoposaurus is present only by a middle-sized ilium (UOPB 00055) where growth marks are visible as two thick avascular annuli with few resting lines in each and two zones (Fig.
The taxonomic affinity of the smallest ilium (UOBS 02917) is even more uncertain. Despite the surface of the cross- section being similarly large to the middle-sized bone, no clear growth marks are preserved, and no rest lines can be observed. The only fragment where a form of cyclical growth can be observed shows a change of matrix type from a fine organized parallel-fibred and moderately vascularized zone to a coarse parallel-fibred, almost avascular layer (Fig.
Considering all histological characters, like the lack of LAGs, high amount of Sharpey’s fibers and coarse matrix, all three ilia sectioned here most probably represent an ontogenetic series of Metoposaurus. However, it shows as well that more intensive studies of the pelvic bones are necessary to distinguish between juvenile forms of Cyclotosaurus and adult metoposaurids.
Interestingly, the ilium of Panthasaurus maleriensis comparable in size (51 mm) to the described herein small bone UOBS 02917, shows a similar growth pattern (
In our study, only one ischium was histologically sectioned, and its histological framework confirms that the bone belongs to Metoposaurus. Even if the annulus is much thinner than in the ilia, it is still massive when compared to the zone and it preserves rest lines. Interestingly the ischium shows preservation of calcified cartilage, which is present not only as a cover on the external surfaces, but also between the trabeculae (Fig.
Most of the skeletochronology studies are usually based on the long bones, especially femora, as they usually preserve the best record of growth marks due to easy morphology and early ossification. Among Temnospondyli the femora are rare and not always accessible for histological studies, thus it is important to test if other skeletal elements are informative enough for microanatomy and skeletochronology.
Based on the presence of preserved growth marks in the form of zones and annuli and the estimated number of the growth marks lost through bone remodeling, the individual age of the smallest ilium (UOBS 02917) can be calculated up to two years (one cycle visible, one lost) and the middle-sized ilium (UOPB 00055) as three years (two cycles visible, one lost) (Table
In Metoposaurus the estimated number of cycles in the pelvic elements is very close to the age calculated for the correspondingly long femora (Table
The bone microstructure is not only a useful tool to interpretate the mode of life of extinct taxa (
The entire ischium shows osteoporotic conditions (Fig.
Based on micro-CT data the ilium of Metoposaurus also shows osteoporotic conditions with the most compact bone restricted to the middle part of the blade (Fig.
The histological framework of the pelvic elements supports the results of the trackway analyses suggesting that among metoposaurids the hind limbs were less involved in underwater locomotion than the forelimbs (Mujal et al. 2020,
The histological characters of pelvic elements of Metoposaurus krasiejowensis from the Late Triassic of Krasiejów are similar to those known from its long bones (
We are thankful to Adam Bodzioch and Mateusz Antczak (both from the University of Opole) for providing access to specimens and permission to section the material. We are also very grateful to Olaf Dülfer (University of Bonn) for the preparation of histological thin sections. We appreciate the help of Sudipta Kalita (University of Dayton, Ohio) for assistance with the correction of the English language. We thank the Editor Florian Witzmann, and two anonymous reviewers, for their corrections and comments which greatly improved the manuscript. This is contribution number 5 of the DFG Research Unit 5581 'Evolution of life histories in early tetrapods'.