Research Article |
|
Corresponding author: Vicente D. Crespo ( vidacres@gmail.com ) Academic editor: Johannes Müller
© 2025 Vicente D. Crespo, María Ríos, Rafael Marquina-Blasco, Plini Montoya.
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Citation:
Crespo VD, Ríos M, Marquina-Blasco R, Montoya P (2025) The Early Miocene muroids (Muroidea, Rodentia) of the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (Spain): A thriving haven during a time of migration. Fossil Record 28(1): 187-218. https://doi.org/10.3897/fr.28.138478
|
The Campisano Ravine in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (Spain, Early Miocene, Biozone C, MN 4) yielded a diverse and abundant assemblage of muroids, comprising five distinct taxa, and nearly 700 remains. The assemblage yielded five muroid taxa: Megacricetodon primitivus, Democricetodon decipiens, Eumyarion weinfurteri, Melissiodon sp., and Muroidea indet. The most abundant taxa were M. primitivus and D. decipiens, with M. primitivus being the most prevalent in the oldest sites and D. decipiens in the most recent ones. E. weinfurteri was exclusively identified in the FS1, MAB3, and MAB5 sites of the most recent biozone (L. ellipticus, see Crespo et al. 2021). In contrast, Melissiodon sp. was confined to the BC-1 and MAB-3 sites. M. primitivus was present in all Iberian basins, whereas D. decipiens exhibited considerable variability, being recorded in the Ca biozone of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin, the last part of the C biozone of the Vallès-Penedès Basin, and the Buñol site. It can be hypothesised that the studied basin may be a factor in the distribution of this species across the regions in question. Eumyarion was present in the Vallès-Penedès Basin from the first part of the C biozone, subsequently migrating to the studied basin and appearing in the Cb biozone in the Calatayud-Montalbán and Buñol basins. Melissiodon was absent from the latter basin from the MN3 biozone to the last part of the C biozone and from the MN5 biozone in the Vallès-Penedès Basin. The presence of muroid faunas in the Early Miocene suggests that the coastal Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin functioned as a transitional region between the forested areas of west and central Europe and the drier inner Iberian Peninsula basins.
Aragonian, biostratigraphy, cricetids, Iberian Peninsula, muroids, palaeoecology
The superfamily Muroidea constitutes the second-largest family of mammals, comprising more than 870 species, including hamsters, New World rats and mice, and arvicolids (
The faunal exchanges are particularly evident during the lower Aragonian, specifically in the lower part of MN4, due to the immigration of muroids of Asian origin. During this period, at least three migrations of muroids have been documented in the Iberian Peninsula, at least in the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin (
In the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin,
The study of the muroids in this basin provides further insight into the ecosystem of the Araia d’Alcora outcrop in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin at the end of the Early Miocene. Notable contributions to the field include the discovery of the new species Plesiodimylus ilercavonicus
The outcrop of Araia d’Alcora in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is located in the eastern part of the Iberian Peninsula, encompassing the vicinity of the village of the same name in Castelló, Spain (see Fig.
The Campisano Ravine is composed of grey and yellow mudstones, limestones, and sandstones, with a total thickness of approximately 100 m (
The examined sections display a stratigraphic sequence that corresponds to part of the local biozone C in the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin (MN4, early Aragonian, Early Miocene), covering a time range from 16.5 to 15.94 million years, as established by
The fossil material under study is currently stored at the Natural History Museum of the University of Valencia (
Lower teeth are designated with lower-case letters (lower molars: m1, m2, and m3). Upper teeth are written in upper-case letters (upper molars: M1, M2, and M3). MCX: Mas dels Coixos; MTR: Mas de Torner; ACS: Araia Cantera Sud; BC: Barranc de Campisano; FS: Foieta la Sarra; MAB: Mas d’Antolino B; CBR: Corral de Brisca.
Suborder Myomorpha Brandt, 1855
Infraorder Myodonta Schaub, 1955
Superfamily Muroidea Illiger, 1811
Subfamily Megacricetodontinae Mein & Freudenthal, 1971
Megacricetodon gregarious (Schaub, 1925), La Grive M, Upper Miocene.
MCX2, MCX3, MCX4, MTR1, MTR2, MTR3, BC1, BC2, FS1, MAB0A, MAB0B, MAB2, MAB3, MAB4, MAB5, MAB11, MAB11B, MAB12, CBR0B, CBR0E, CBR0F, CBR1, CBR2, and CBR4.
Suppl. material
Suppl. material
(See Suppl. material
Mandible
(MCX3; Fig.
Concerning other sites, no significant disparities were observed in the material of MCX2.
Lower teeth of Megacricetodon primitivus from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. A. Left mandible+m2+m3 (MCX3-33); B. Right m1 (MCX3-73); C. Right m1 (MTR2-72); D. Left m1 (BC1-55); E. Right m1 (MAB0B-10); F. Right m1 (MAB5-9); G. Right m1 (MAB5-61); H. Right m1 (MAB5-499); I. Left m1 (MAB5-798); J. Right m1, labial view (MCX3-65); K. Right m2 (MCX3-78); L. Left m2 (BC1-70); M. Left m2 (MAB3-170); N. Right m2 (MAB3-171); O. Right m2 (MAB3-172); P. Left m2 (MAB3-173); Q. Right m2 (MAB5-540); R. Right m2 (CBR0B-13); S. Left m3 (MCX3-87); T. Right m3 (BC1-71); U. Left m3 (MAB2-2); V. Right m3 (MAB3-6); W. Left m3 (MAB3-209); X. Left m3 (MAB3-213); Y. Right m3 (MAB3-214); Z. Right m3 (MAB3-219); AA. Right m3 (MAB5-512); AB. Right m3 (MAB5-803). Scale bar: 1 mm.
m1
(MAB5; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In the remains of MCX2 and MCX3 (Fig.
Comparison of length and width measurements (in mm) of Megacricetodon primitivus from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. M. primitivus from Valtorres (type locality (t.l.)); M. vandermeuleni from Fuente Sierra 4 (t.l.); M. hellenicus from Aliveri NQ (t.l.); M. collongensis from Vieux Collonges (l.t.); M. bezianensis from Bézian; M. bavaricus from Langenmoosen (t.l.); and the material from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (
m2
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MCX3 (Fig.
m3
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MCX3 (Fig.
M1
(MAB3; Fig.
Upper teeth of Megacricetodon primitivus from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. A. Right M1 (MTR2-47); B. Right M1 (BC1-33); C. Right M1 (BC1-36); D. Right M1 (MAB0A-22); E. Left M1 (MAB3-53); F. Left M1 (MAB3-57); G. Left M1 (MAB3-59); H. Right M1 (MAB3-62); I. Left M1 (MAB3-66); J. Left M1 (MAB5-78); K. Left M1 (MAB11-1); L. Right M1 (CBR1-12); M. Left M2 (MCX3-51); N. Left M2 (BC1-46); O. Right M2 (FS1-20); P. Left M2 (MAB3-87); Q. Left M2 (MAB5-65); R. Right M2 (MAB5-74); S. Right M2 (MAB5-489); T. Right M2 (MAB5-509); U. Left M2 (MAB11-31); V. Left M2 (CBR1-1); W. Left M3 (MCX3-59); X. Left M3 (MTR2-204); Y. Right M3 (BC1-53); Z. Left M3 (MAB3-112); AA. Left M3 (MAB3-114); AB. Left M3 (MAB3-118); AC. Left M3 (MAB5-13); AD. Left M3 (MAB5-62); AE. Left M3 (MAB5-494); AF. Left M3 (MAB5-809). Scale bar: 1 mm.
Variability in other sites: In the M1 of MCX3, there is a higher prevalence of uniform size anterocone cusps, the absence of a double protolophule, the anterolophule connection with the lingual cusp, the ectoloph is absent in one specimen, and the mesoloph is long and lack of contact with the posterior crest of the paracone. In M1 from MTR2 (Fig.
M2
(MAB5; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MCX3 (Fig.
M3 (MAB5; Fig. 4AC–AF): the lingual anteroloph and the protosinus may be poorly developed (2 out of 11) or absent (9 out of 11). The labial anteroloph may be short (5 out of 11) or long (6 out of 11), connecting with the paracone (7 out of 11) or not (4 out of 11). This morphology of the labial anteroloph influences the presence of a short but relatively wide anterosinus (2 out of 11), a long anterosinus (6 out of 11), or the absence of an anterosinus (3 out of 11). The metalophule (centroloph) may be connected to the neo-entoloph (3 out of 11), to the anterior ridge of the hypocone (4 out of 11), to the anterior ridge of the hypocone and protolophule (2 out of 11), to the posterior ridge of the protocone (1 out of 11) or the axioloph (1 out of 11). The sinus may be shallow (4 out of 11) or deep (7 out of 11). The mesoloph may be long (2 out of 11), short (4 out of 11), incipient (2 out of 11), or absent (3 out of 11). The neo-entoloph may be short and connected to the protocone and hypocone (8 out of 11) or absent (3 out of 11). The axioloph may be incipient (3 out of 11) or absent (8 out of 11). The posteroloph may be long and curved (10 out of 11) or straight (1 out of 11), forming a labial wall together with the metacone and the posterior wall of the paracone (7 out of 11), and may not connect with the metacone (4 out of 11).
Variability in other sites: In MCX3 (Fig.
The genus Megacricetodon has been the focus of significant research interest due to its abundance and wide distribution during the Early and Middle Miocene (
The species M. primitivus, in conjunction with Megacricetodon bezianensis Bulot, 1980, represents the most primitive species identified in south-western Europe (
The populations of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin, as meticulously documented by
The material under study is distinguished from other small and medium-sized species of this genus from Europe and Turkey by its relatively smaller size, Megacricetodon andrewsi Peláez-Campomanes & Daams, 2002, Megacricetodon similis (Fahlbusch, 1964), and Megacricetodon grueneri Čermák et al., 2022 (
Given the substantial number of localities in which this species is present, a comparison was made between the present material and that from the localities of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin. The most numerous population from each of the localities, Ca (Artesilla), Cb (Vargas 1a), and the type locality (Valtorres, MN5, local area Db), was selected for analysis (
In the M1s of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin, the anterocone generally exhibits a small anterior platform; however, in a smaller proportion of specimens, this feature is absent, and in a lesser degree, the anterocones display a small cingulum or the anterocone is barely divided. In the material studied, this form is dominant only in MTR2. In the remaining localities, the presence of this anterior platform or the cingulum is exceedingly rare. It is noteworthy that MAB5 contains multiple specimens exhibiting a slight division of the anterocone. About the symmetry of the anterocone of M1, the prevailing morphology in the populations used for comparisons is that in which the labial cusp is larger than the lingual cusp, except Artesilla, where the two cusps are almost of the same size. A similar phenomenon is observed in the localities of the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, where something similar occurs, where three sites (MCX3, MAB5, and CBR1) exhibit comparable sizes between the anterocone cusps. In the type locality, the connection of the anteroloph of M1 to the anterocone occurs at similar frequencies along the middle part of the cusps of the anterocone or on the lingual cusp, with a slightly higher frequency in the latter case.
In the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, except MAB3 and MAB5, where both morphologies are represented in equal proportions, there is a striking prevalence of the anteroloph attached to the lingual cusp in the remaining materials. The presence of the partially developed or incipient labial ridge of the anteroloph of M1 is an infrequent occurrence in the localities with which it is compared. In contrast, it is similar in our localities, with the incipient stage slightly more common. The protoloph of M1 in the localities used for comparisons of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin is predominantly single and posterior, with a lesser prevalence of complete or interrupted double forms. These also occur in our material, although in MAB3 the dominant form is that with the small unconnected ridge.
Concerning the lingual mesocingulum of M1, the number of individuals exhibiting a robust lingual mesocingulum was documented in the populations utilised for comparisons. This character is not particularly prevalent in the material under consideration. However, when only the presence or absence of the mesocingulum-anteroloph connection is considered, the proportions are similar or even higher. The ectoloph is typically longer in the localities of the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin than in the localities used for comparisons of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin, and a comparable development is observed solely at the Artesilla site. In contrast, the number of connections with the mesoloph is very similar in both groups of localities. The mesoloph of M1 demonstrates a comparable development, except for MCX3, where they are longer. At the same time, the metalophule of M1 is predominantly connected to the base of the posteroloph in the localities used for comparisons. In the localities of the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, there is material where a posteriorly directed metalophule dominates, thereby reducing the size of the posterosinus.
Regarding the development of the M2 protolophule, in most of the populations utilised for comparisons, it is anterior, or an incomplete posterior protolophule manifests with significantly reduced frequency, and the transverse, double, or posterior forms are residual. Conversely, within the material studied, the proportions observed in the sites belonging to the L. florancei biozone are consistent with those seen in other populations, while in the sites belonging to the L. ellipticus biozone, the transverse forms predominate. The ectoloph’s length and percentage of connections with the mesoloph are comparable. Notably, the ectoloph-mesoloph junction is generally less frequent in the oldest deposits belonging to the local L. florancei biozone of the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. The development of the M2 metalophule is very similar in both populations, with the anterior form dominating, although the transverse form predominates in MCX3 and the posterior metalophule in MAB0A.
The morphology of the metalophule of M3 is similar in both basins, predominantly connected to the anterior ridge of the hypocone, except for the exception of BC1, where the majority of specimens are devoid of a metalophule.
In m1, the anteroconid is consistently simple, although at very low frequencies, the populations employed for comparisons from the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin may be slightly divided. The labial ridge of the m1 anterolophulid is predominantly absent in both basins, although incipient ridges are well represented in BC1 and well-developed ridges are present in Vargas 1A. The anterior metalophulid of m1 is present in the majority of specimens from both basins, more frequently separated from the protoconid in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin than in the populations used for comparisons of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin. The mesolophid lengths of m1, m2, and m3 are similar in the localities of both basins, although in m2 of the localities studied, there are proportionally more specimens that reach the labial edge. On the other hand, the mesolophids of m3 occur only in the more modern deposits belonging to local biozone L. ellipticus in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. The absence of ectomesolophids in m1 and the length of the anterolophid of m2 (short) are similar in both basins. Although in the latter case, the length of the m2 anterolophid is shorter, the well-developed form is more abundant in the MCX3, BC1, and MAB5 sites.
The specimens from the Calatayud-Montalbán and the Ribesalbes-Alcora basins studied here are similar in size (see Fig.
In relation to the Buñol zone, the Barranco de Candel site is distinguished by the following features in comparison with our material: one specimen with a slightly bilobed anteroconid of the M1; the anterolophid of the M2 is typically more developed; the M2 mesolophid is longer; the M1 ectolophs are more prevalent; and the M1 mesolophs are longer. Regarding biometrics, the specimens from the Barranco del Candel site are broadly similar to those studied from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, although the M1s are slightly smaller (
In the Morteral section (1–20A), within the Magro Basin (including M. primitivus and some taxa in open nomenclature (Megacricetodon sp. 1 and 2), the morphology of these taxa is similar. However, there are some differences when compared to our sites. In the more modern sites, there are representatives with a slightly doubled anteroconid of m1 and shorter mesolophids. The m2 exhibits a slightly shorter mesolophid, and the labial ridge of the anterolophid of M1 is less frequently observed. The ectoloph of the M1 is longer. In M2, there is a reduction in the number of partially double and transverse protolophids. Furthermore, in the more modern deposits, the ectoloph is more frequently attached to the mesoloph. The metalophule of M2 exhibits a comparable morphology, with the exception of MCX3, where it is transverse. Biometrically, they are similar, except for Megacricetodon sp. 2, which has larger lower molars, and the upper molars are of a similar size (
In the Vallès-Penedès Basin, the remains analysed in this study demonstrate notable similarities to those exhibited by the material found in the following sites: Can Julià 6 and Can Martí Vell I and II, Els Casots 73 and 76. However, a distinguishing feature emerges in the analysis of Can Martí Vell I, where the protolophid is consistently located posteriorly, and the mesolophid of m1 is typically shorter. Biometrically, the material from Catalonia corresponds with the material studied here, including the Megacricetodon sp. described by
In the Loranca Basin, particularly at the La Retama site, the mesoloph of M1 is characterised by a reduction in length, the lingual mesocingulum exhibits increased prevalence, the protolophule is posteriorly positioned, and the metalophule is anteriorly situated. In the M2, the mesoloph is shorter; in the M1, there is a higher prevalence of divided anteroconids. In the m2, the lingual anterolophid is less prevalent, and the mesolophids are shorter in length. Biometrically, M2, m2, and m3 are typically smaller in size (
Therefore, the morphological and biometric study of the material of M. primitivus is in accordance with the findings of
Democricetodon crassus Freudenthal, 1969. Sansan, Middle Miocene.
MCX1, MCX3, MTR1, MTR2, BC1, FS1, MAB0A, MAB0B, MAB3, MAB5, MAB10, MAB11, MAB13, CBR0B, and CBR1.
Suppl. material
Suppl. material
(See Suppl. material
m1
(MAB3; Fig.
Lower teeth of Democricetodon decipiens from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. A. Right m1 (MTR2-80); B. Left m1 (BC1-57); C. Left m1 (MAB3-152); D. Left m1 (MAB3-154); E. Right m1 (MAB3-156); F. Right m1 (MAB3-164); G. Right m1 (MAB5-188); H. Left m1 (MAB5-530); I. Left m1 (MAB10-1); J. Left m1 (MAB11-39); K. Left m1, labial view (MAB3-157); L. Left m2 (MTR2-3); M. Left m2 (MTR2-93); N. Right m2 (MTR2-94); O. Left m2 (MAB3-191); P. Left m2 (MAB3-195); Q. Right m2 (MAB3-196); R. Right m2 (MAB3-201); S. Right m2 (MAB5-197); T. Right m2 (MAB11-2); U. Left m2 (MAB11-45); V. Left m2 (CBR0B-1); W. Right m3 (MTR2-98); X. Right m3 (MAB0B-15); Y. Left m3 (FS1-31); Z. Left m3 (MAB3-224); AA. Right m3 (MAB3-228); AB. Left m3 (MAB3-231); AC. Right m3 (MAB3-233); AD. Left m3 (MAB5-544); AE. Right m3 (MAB5-545); AF. Right m3 (MAB11-53). Scale bar: 1 mm.
Variability in other sites: In MCX3 the metalophulid is absent and the hypolophulid is transverse. In MTR2 (Fig.
Comparison of length and width measurements (in mm) of Democricetodon decipiens from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. D. hispanicus from Villafeliche 2A (type locality (t.l.)); D. decipiens from Buñol (t.l.); D. moralesi from La Col (l.t.); D. franconicus from Erkertshofen (l.t.); D. sacedonensis from Córcoles; and the material from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (
m2
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MTR2 (Fig.
m3
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MTR2 (Fig.
M1
(MAB3; Fig.
Upper teeth of Democricetodon decipiens from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. A. Right M1 (MCX1-1); B. Left M1 (MTR2-56); C. Left M1 (MAB3-70); D. Right M1 (MAB3-74); E. Right M1 (MAB3-77); F. Right M1 (MAB3-78); G. Right M1 (MAB5-516); H. Right M1 (MAB11-18); I. Right M1 (MAB11-19); J. Left M1 (MAB11-20); K. Right M2 (MTR2-62); L. Left M2 (MTR2-63); M. Left M2 (MAB3-96); N. Left M2 (MAB3-105); O. Left M2 (MAB3-110); P. Left M2 (MAB3-194); Q. Left M2 (MAB5-520); R. Left M2 (MAB11-3); S. Right M2 (MAB11-25); T. Right M2 (MAB11-28); U. Right M3 (MTR2-69); V. Left M3 (BC1-51); W. Left M3 (MAB3-124); X. Left M3 (MAB3-125); Y. Left M3 (MAB3-127); Z. Right M3 (MAB3-128); AA. Left M3 (MAB5-227); AB. Right M3 (MAB5-228); AC. Left M3 (MAB5-229); AD. Left M3 (MAB11-37). Scale bar: 1 mm.
Variability in other sites: In MCX1 (Fig.
M2
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MTR2 (Fig.
M3
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: The mesoloph contacts the paracone in MTR2 (Fig.
The taxonomic status of the genus Democricetodon has been the subject of extensive debate in the literature (
The provenance of the genus under consideration may be located in Anatolia, with the first records in Turkey immediately following the MN1. In contrast, the earliest evidence of the genus in China and Europe is not until MN3/4 (
This genus is clearly distinguishable from the species of muroids present in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, which are assigned to Megacricetodon and Eumyarion, by virtue of its intermediate size and more rounded teeth. Furthermore, Democricetodon differs from Megacricetodon in having an undivided anterocone of M1 and a generally more complex tooth pattern. Compared to Eumyarion, it exhibits a more simplified and advanced pattern (
The material under discussion is compared with that described by
In the M1 from the localities of the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, the anterocones are simple, as in the species D. hispanicus, D. decipiens, Democricetodon moralesi
Relation Length/Width of Democricetodon decipiens from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. D. hispanicus from Villafeliche 2A (type locality (t.l.)); D. decipiens from Buñol (t.l.); D. moralesi from La Col (l.t.); D. franconicus from Erkertshofen (l.t.); D. sacedonensis from Córcoles; and the material from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (
| Element | Site | n | Min. | Med. | Max. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| m1 | MTR2 | 1 | 1.51 | ||
| BC1 | 1 | 1.41 | |||
| MAB0A | 1 | 1.40 | |||
| MAB3 | 11 | 1.39 | 1.49 | 1.64 | |
| MAB5 | 10 | 1.33 | 1.44 | 1.53 | |
| MAB10 | 1 | 1.60 | |||
| MAB11 | 3 | 1.47 | 1.48 | 1.50 | |
| Villafeliche 2 | 1.41 | ||||
| Buñol | 1.42 | ||||
| La Col D | 1.47 | ||||
| Erkertshofen | 1.45 | ||||
| Córcoles | 1.46 | ||||
| M1 | MCX1 | 1 | 1.60 | ||
| MTR2 | 1 | 1.62 | |||
| MAB3 | 10 | 1.46 | 1.56 | 1.67 | |
| MAB5 | 7 | 1.42 | 1.55 | 1.63 | |
| MAB11 | 6 | 1.42 | 1.50 | 1.57 | |
| Villafeliche 2 | 1.46 | ||||
| Buñol | 1.5 | ||||
| La Col D | 1.55 | ||||
| Erkertshofen | 1.5 | ||||
| Córcoles | 1.53 |
In the M2, the mesolophs of the material from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin are of a medium-long length, as observed in D. franconicus, D. hispanicus, and D. decipiens. In this regard, the former exhibits a longer length than that observed in D. moralesi and D. sacedonensis. The ectoloph is absent in D. hispanicus and is very poorly represented in D. franconicus, D. decipiens, and D. moralesi, as observed in the localities studied. In the material under consideration, protolophules are predominantly double and metalophules are primarily anterior, as seen in D. decipiens, D. franconicus, and D. sacedonensis. The size of the material from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is generally larger than that of D. hispanicus from Villafeliche 2A, smaller than that of D. moralesi from La Col D, and similar to that of D. decipiens from Buñol, D. franconicus from Erkertshofen, and D. sacedonensis from Córcoles.
The M3 from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is comparable in size to D. hispanicus, D. franconicus, and D. decipiens, with a narrower width than D. sacedonensis and a smaller overall size than D. moralesi.
For the m1, while in D. hispanicus the anteroconid-metaconid contact is invariably present, in D. decipiens it is present in approximately half of the examined remains. At the same time, in D. franconicus it is highly variable. In D. moralesi and D. sacedonensis, the contact is present in only a few specimens. In the material studied, something similar to D. decipiens occurs, tending to have a higher percentage of connections in the localities belonging to the L. florancei local biozone. However, there are only a few specimens in these sites. On the other hand, in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin, the metalophulid is anterior, rarely transverse or absent, whereas in D. franconicus, the metalophulid is usually transverse, in D. sacedonensis transverse or anterior, and variable in the rest. The mesolophid of the material from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is typically long, as in D. hispanicus, and shorter in D. decipiens, D. franconicus, D. sacedonensis, and D. moralesi. The remaining morphologies of m1 are analogous to those previously documented for D. hispanicus, D. franconicus, D. sacedonensis, D. decipiens, and D. moralesi. With regard to size, the material from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is typically larger than D. hispanicus from Villafeliche 2A, smaller than D. moralesi from La Col D, and of the same size as D. decipiens from Buñol, D. sacedonensis from Córcoles, and D. franconicus from Erkertshofen. The L/W index indicates that the studied material falls within the variability of one of the described species (Table
The mesolophid m2 from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin material is characterised by either a short or, on rare occasions, a long form, with a length comparable to that of the species D. franconicus, D. hispanicus, D. decipiens, and D. moralesi, and shorter than that of D. sacedonensis. The size of the m2 from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is typically larger than those of D. hispanicus from Villafeliche 2A, smaller than those of D. moralesi from La Col D, and D. sacedonensis from Córcoles, and very similar to those of D. decipiens from Buñol and D. franconicus from Erkertshofen.
The m3 from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin exhibits mesolophids in the local L. florancei biozone localities, although the number of identified remains of this element is limited. Such occurrences are absent in D. sacedonensis and observed only infrequently in D. hispanicus and D. decipiens. The size of the m3 in this study is generally larger than that of D. hispanicus from Villafeliche 2A, smaller than that of D. moralesi from La Col D, not as wide as that of D. sacedonensis from Córcoles, and very similar in size to that of D. decipiens from Buñol and D. franconicus from Erkertshofen.
The material under study exhibits notable disparities compared with other European species of the genus Democricetodon of the same age. It is distinguished from Democricetodon anatolicus Theocharopoulos, 2000 by its larger size and more robust anteroconid (
Compared with all previously documented Democricetodon species, it can be concluded that the Democricetodon material from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin localities can be assigned to D. decipiens. Its morphology and size fall within the range of intrapopulation variability, and it exhibits novel morphological features not observed in any other species of the genus, including the mesolophs and the double labial ridges of the anteroloph of MAB11.
Cricetodon medium Lartet, 1851 (=Cricetodon helveticum Schaub, 1925). Sansan, Middle Miocene.
FS1, MAB3, and MAB5.
Suppl. material
Suppl. material
m1
(MAB3; Fig.
Teeth of Eumyarion weinfurteri, Melissiodon sp., and Muroidea indet. From the Ribersalbes-Alcora-Basin. Eumyarion weinfurteri: A. Left m1 (MAB3-161); B. Left m1 (MAB3-162); C. Right m1 (MAB5-75); D. Left m1 (MAB5-76); E. Right m2 (FS1-29); F. Left m2 (MAB3-203); G. Right m2 (MAB3-206); H. Left m2 (MAB5-53); I. Right m2 (MAB5-54); J. Left m3 (MAB3-241); K. Right m3 (MAB3-242); L. Left m3 (MAB5-56); M. Right m3 (MAB5-57); N. Right M1 (MAB3-82); O. Left M1 (MAB3-83); P. Right M1 (MAB5-515); Q. Left M2 (MAB3-111); R. Right M3 (MAB3-133); S. Left M3 (MAB3-134); T. Left M3 (MAB3-135). Melissiodon sp.: U. Right m1 (MAB3-168); V. Left m3 (MAB3-169); W. Left M1 (BC1-32); X. Left M3 (BC1-31); Y. Left M3 (MAB3-727). Muroidea indet.: Z. Right M2 (MAB0A-43). Scale bar: 1 mm.
Variability in other sites: in MAB5 (Fig.
Comparison of length and width measurements (in mm) of Eumyarion weinfurteri from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. E. latior from Neudorf (type locality (t.l.); E. weinfurteri from Puttenhausen (t.l.); E. montanus from Keseköy (l.t.); E. bifidus from Sandelzhausen (t.l.); E. medius from Untereichen Altenstadt 565; E. carbonicus from Harami 1 (t.l); and the material from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (
m2
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability at other sites: FS1 (Fig.
m3
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability in other sites: in MAB5 (Fig.
M1
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability is present in other sites: in MAB5 (Fig.
M2
(MAB3; Fig.
M3
(MAB3; Fig.
Variability is present in other sites: the tooth from MAB5 is similar to the one described before.
The genus Eumyarion is a small to medium-sized muroid characterized by primitive dental features (
The provenance of this genus has been the subject of considerable debate among scholars, with various authors proposing a range of potential locations. These include the upper Oligocene in Turkey (
In the Iberian Peninsula, the earliest fossil records date from the lower Aragonian (upper part of the MN4), specifically at the localities of Buñol (Cerro de la Cruz, Magro River Basin, last part of the local biozone C;
The classification of medium-sized Eumyarion poses a considerable challenge, primarily due to the extensive intraspecific variation observed in their morphology and size. This observation has prompted several researchers to synonymise species and question the homogeneity of populations (
The material of the genus Eumyarion recovered from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin exhibits a larger size compared to the smaller species of the genus (namely Eumyarion intercentralis de Bruijn & Saraç, 1991, Eumyarion microps de Bruijn & Saraç, 1991), E. gordensensis, and E. orhani. It is slightly larger than the type population of E. weinfurteri (although resembling other populations of this species), E. bifidus, and E. carbonicus, and exhibits similarities with E. aegeaniensis, E. beyderensis, E. montanus, and E. medius. However, in comparison to E. latior, it is similar or slightly smaller, depending on the specific element (Fig.
The MAB3 sample exhibits a combination of primitive and derived features in the m1 morphology, with one specimen displaying an anteroconid that is strikingly similar to that of E. orhani or Eumyarion tremulus Lopatin, 1996, and lacking protoconid-anteroconid contact. In the remaining material, the anteroconid has a decreasing crescent shape and it is connected to the metaconid and protoconid by a well-developed anterolophulid, a feature typical of E. carbonicus or E. latior/weinfurteri (
The morphology of m2 is distinctive. In 33% of the specimens, the posterior ridge of the protoconid is present, a feature that is more commonly seen in more recent species. Conversely, the short or absent mesolophid is a characteristic of more primitive species. This combination of morphologies is a characteristic of E. latior/weinfurteri from Aliveri and Eumyarion margueritae from
The m3 has no mesolophid, the posterior crest of the hypoconid is absent, and the posterior crest of the protoconid is medium to long. These characteristics are comparable to those found in E. latior/weinfurteri de Aliveri and E. margueritae, yet still shorter than those of the Buñol population (
The M1 is distinguished by the variability and complexity of the posterior spurs of the anterocone, exhibiting a morphology analogous to that observed in E. latior/weinfurteri populations from Aliveri or Dolnice 1 (
A single M2 has been identified at the MAB3 locality, and it is characterised by a small posterior paracone spur. This morphology is similar to that described in E. montanus from Keseköy and E. weinfurteri from Sandelzhausen or Bézian (
The morphology of the third molar exhibits considerable variation, with the axioloph potentially being either complete with a long mesoloph or incomplete with a short mesoloph. The former combination has been observed in E. montanus or early populations of E. latior/weinfurteri (
As posited by
Melissiodon dominans Schaub, 1925. Wintershof-West. Early Miocene.
BC1 and MAB3.
Suppl. material
Suppl. material
m1
(MAB3; Fig.
m3
(MAB3; Fig.
M1
(BC1; Fig.
M3
(BC1; Fig.
Variability in other sites: In MAB3 (Fig.
Comparison of length and width measurements (in mm) of Melissiodon sp. from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin. M. dominans from Erkertshofen 1, Dolnice 1, Montalvos 2, Petersbuch 2, Sant Andreu de la Barca, and Wintershof West (type locality (t.l.); M. aff. dominans from Beaulieu 2B, and Vieux Collonges; Melissiodon sp. from Beón 2; and the material from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (
The Melissiodontinae family is thought to have a primitive origin, as it probably first appeared in the early-middle Eocene of Asia (
The fossil record of Melissiodon in the Early Miocene of the Iberian Peninsula is mainly limited to a few isolated teeth or tooth fragments recovered from several sites in the eastern part of the Iberian Peninsula. These sites include Level Q of Barranco del Candel (Magro Basin;
The material from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (Fig.
The m1 of MAB3 is notably intricate, exhibiting a distinctive set of characters that are not observed in any population of the genus Melissiodon. The mesolophid is isolated, making contact exclusively with the mesoconid. Additionally, there is direct contact between the posterior metalophulid and the entoconid, and no contact between the metaconid and the posterior metalophulid. This differs from the descriptions provided by
The primary concerns regarding the lower Aragonian collections of this genus pertain to the scarcity of remains (less than 1% of all mammals), the substantial degree of fragmentation of the remains, and the challenge in discerning the morphology of the small tooth fragments belonging to this genus. Consequently, the classification of these specimens is often uncertain (
The distinguishing characteristics between M. schlosseri and M. dominans are as follows: the former exhibits greater cusp thickness, while the latter possesses a squarer m1 with a labial anteroconid that is slightly extended in the latter. The labial anteroconid of M. dominans from Wintershof West (
Consequently, upon thorough review of extant literature from multiple European localities, it was determined that specific populations of M. aff. dominans could be re-assigned to M. schlosseri, as evidenced by the findings in Vieux Collonges (Mein and Freudenthal 1981). This underscores the imperative for a comprehensive re-evaluation of the genus and its potential re-classification. Furthermore, the m1 from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin exhibits a smaller size compared to those previously described by Mein and Freudenthal (1981). The m1 from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin is distinguished by an isolated mesolophid with an isolated on the anterior part and a slightly elongated labial anteroconid. These characteristics differentiate it from M. dominans from Central Europe and the Vallès-Penedès Basin. It is a closer alignment with M. aff. dominans (
In consideration of the aforementioned morphological characteristics, the specimen exhibits primitive traits analogous to those observed in the Wintershof West population. It is comparable in size to the recently discovered but as yet unnamed species from Beon. Furthermore, the characteristics of the genus Melissiodon exhibit a high degree of variability, and the available comparative material is exceedingly scarce (
Fig.
Localities. MAB0A.
Material (number of remains). MAB0A (1): 1 M2.
Description. M2 (MAB0A; Fig.
Remarks. The tooth fragment displays characteristics consistent with those observed in Eumyarion, Pseudocricetodon, or Eucricetodon, including the presence of double mesolophs and the posterior crest of the hypocone. Given its diminutive dimensions and the presence of a double protoloph, it seems not plausible that this specimen can be attributed to the Eumyarion species identified at other localities. The Turkish fossil record is replete with small Eumyarion species, yet one m1 has been described from the Blanquàtere 1 location, which belongs to one of these species (
The complicated primitive morphology of the taxon precludes its categorisation within any specific genus. If the specimen were determined to belong to Eumyarion, it would represent the earliest known appearance of this genus in the Levantine basins from the Iberian Peninsula. Conversely, if the specimen belonged to Eucricetodon, it would represent the surviving member of the genus following the absence of representatives of the European MN3 following the Cricetid Vacuum (
The muroid family is a frequently employed biostratigraphic indicator for the Neogene period (
Percentages of relative abundance of muroids per site with respect to the total number of rodents in the most representative sites of the Iberian Peninsula from MN4-5, together with the main sites studied here. The graph shows the increase in abundance towards the end of MN4 and the beginning of MN5 (OR9). The order of the sites is hypothesised from the literature, the alteration of the order within each group, does not alter the trend. SR: San Roque; OR: Olmo Redondo; VL: Villafeliche; ART: Artesilla; MCX: Mas dels Coixos; MTR: Mas de Torner; BC: Barranc de Campisano; MAB: Mas d’Antolino B; Bar. Cand: Barranc de Candel; BÑ: Buñol; VR: Vargas; FS: Foieta la Sarra; Mon2: Montalvos 2; MT1: Morteral 1; CBR: Corral de Brisca. Taken from
As illustrated in Fig.
Composite column of the Campisano Ravine with positions of the studied sites and the different local biozones and subbiozones present in this section, with percentage abundance of Megacricetodon/Democricetodon and Muridae/Mammals at the different sites under study (only sites with a significant collection of small mammal remains are represented). Megacricetodon primitivus is present in the sites: MCX2, MCX3, MCX4, MTR1, MTR2, MTR3, BC1, BC2, FS1, MAB0A, MAB0B, MAB2, MAB3, MAB4, MAB5, MAB11, MAB11B, MAB12, CBR0B, CBR0E, CBR0F, CBR1, CBR2, and CBR4; Democricetodon decipiens is present in the sites: MCX1, MCX3, MTR1, MTR2, BC1, FS1, MAB0A, MAB0B, MAB3, MAB5, MAB10, MAB11, MAB13, CBR0B, and CBR1; Eumyarion weinfurteri is present in the sites: FS1, MAB3, and MAB5; Melissiodon sp. is present in the sites: BC1 and MAB3; and Muroidea indet. is present in the site: MAB0A. Modified from
The record of the muroids in the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin, in the MN3-4 (
In Central Europe, specifically in the Swiss basins, the occurrence of Democricetodon as identified by
The record of the Melissiodon in the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin stops at the end of local zone B, according to
In the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (Fig.
It has been traditionally assumed that the MN4 forms of Democricetodon and Megacricetodon exhibit a preference for humid ecological conditions, mainly due to the mesoloph length. In the case of a shorter length, the environment is believed to be more arid (
In the local biozone L. florancei (MCX3 to MAB0B), the genus Megacricetodon is unquestionably predominant within the muroid faunas, with Democricetodon appearing scarcely. The genus Democricetodon becomes increasingly prevalent at the sites within the local biozone L. ellipticus (MAB3 to CBR1). Indeed, it is the most abundant muroid taxon at the MAB11 and CBR0B sites (as illustrated in Fig.
Melissiodon was traditionally assigned a frugivorous diet based on its tooth morphology, which resembles the Oligocene flying squirrel Plesispermophilus (Mein and Freudenthal 1981). However, the aberrant, frail, and slim mandible of Melissiodon, as previously observed by
The Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin has a continental time sequence that is comparable to the regional biozone C (early Miocene) of the larger Calatayud- Montalbán Basin. It has yielded abundant remains of muroids, including five taxa: Megacricetodon primitivus, Democricetodon decipiens, Eumyarion weinfurteri, Melissiodon sp., and Muroidae indet. The most abundant species, M. primitivus and D. decipiens, were found in nearly all the sites under study. The first species was more prevalent in the oldest sites (L. florancei local biozone). In contrast, the second was more abundant in the most modern ones (L. ellipticus local biozone). Conversely, E. weinfurteri was only observed in the FS1, MAB3, and MAB5 sites, which are part of the most recent local biozone, L. ellipticus, in the basin. In contrast, Melissiodon sp. has been found exclusively in the BC-1 and MAB-3 sites, likely to have experienced drier climatic conditions.
While M. primitivus has been identified in all Early Miocene Iberian basins, the genus Democricetodon is highly variable. The species of this genus have been identified in the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin (D. decipiens), appear in the Ca biozone of the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin, the last part of the C biozone of the Vallès-Penedès Basin, and the Buñol site. The basin under study may represent a link between the distribution of this species in these two regions. Concerning Eumyarion, this genus has been present in the Vallès-Penedès basin since the beginning of the early part of the C biozone. However, it is not until the final part of the C biozone that it begins to migrate towards the basin under study. It only appears in the Cb in the Calatayud-Montalbán Basin and Buñol zone. Conversely, Melissiodon is absent in the latter basin from the MN3 biozone to the last part of the C biozone in Cerro de la Cruz and from the MN5 biozone in the Vallès-Penedès Basin.
Consequently, the muroid faunas imply that during the early Miocene, the coastal Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin functioned as a transitional region between the forested areas of west and central Europe and the drier inner Iberian Peninsula basins.
The survey and excavation campaigns in Araia d’Alcora were funded by the Conselleria de Cultura i Esports of the Generalitat Valenciana from 2008 to 2011, by projects 2008/0433-CS, 2010/0528-CS, 2011/0230-CS, GV06/304, and GVPRE/2008/320. This research was also supported by the Spanish Ministerio de Ciencia, Innovación y Universidades PID2023-151089NB-I00 (MCIU / AEI / 10.13039/501100011033 / FEDER, UE). Thanks are also due to the helpful comments of Dr. López-Guerrero and anonymous reviewers, which improved the original manuscript, and Jarrid Muhlenberg for the English revision of the manuscript. V.D.C. thanks the Stimulus of Scientific Employment, Individual Support – 2021 Call grant by the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (Portugal, CEECIND/03080/2021; DOI: 10.54499/2021.03080.CEECIND/CP1657/CT0007) and GeoBioTec; M.R. thanks the Stimulus of Scientific Employment, Individual Support – 2018 Call grant by the Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia (Portugal, CEECIND/02199/2018) and GeoBioTec. This work was funded by National funding, FCT – Fundação para a Ciência e a Tecnologia, within the framework of UID GeoBioTEC UIDB/04035/2020 (DOI: 10.54499/UIDB/04035/2020). RMB thanks the CIAPOS postdoctoral grant (CIAPOS/2023/160, Generalitat Valenciana), co-financed by the European Social Fund.
Museum numbers
Data type: pdf
Explanation note: These are the museum entry numbers of the fossils studied, as well as their identification, site and field numbers.
Measuremets of the muroids from the Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin
Data type: docx
Megacricetodon primitivus from Ribesalbes-Alcora Basin
Data type: xlsx
M. primitivus and D. decipiens
Data type: xlsx
Explanation note: Text